Skip to main content
A person in a dark hooded coat walks away from the camera down an icy, slush-covered sidewalk between banks of plowed snow.
Slip and Fall

Icy or Broken Sidewalk Fall on Long Island: Is the Homeowner, Store or Town Liable?

By Jason Tenenbaum 17 min read

Key Takeaway

On Long Island the town, not the house next door, usually answers for a public sidewalk, and only after written notice. Who is liable for an icy fall, and when.

This article is part of our ongoing slip and fall coverage, with 2 published articles analyzing slip and fall issues across New York State. Attorney Jason Tenenbaum brings 24+ years of hands-on experience to this analysis, drawing from his work on more than 1,000 appeals, over 100,000 no-fault cases, and recovery of over $100 million for clients throughout Nassau County, Suffolk County, Queens, Brooklyn, Manhattan, and the Bronx. For personalized legal advice about how these principles apply to your specific situation, contact our Long Island office at (516) 750-0595 for a free consultation.

Take an invented example. A commuter walking to the train in Wantagh, in the Town of Hempstead, slips on ice on the public sidewalk in front of a house, two doors down from a deli, two days after a heavy snow. Whose ice was it: the homeowner’s, the deli’s or the town’s? New York answers differently for each, and the answer decides whom she can sue and how fast. Our Long Island slip and fall lawyers answer that question every winter.

The short version

A public sidewalk on Long Island is generally the municipality's responsibility, not the homeowner's or the store's next to it. The owner next door is liable only if it created the condition, made a special use of the sidewalk, or a law both requires it to maintain the walk and expressly makes it liable for injuries; the Town of Hempstead's snow-clearing ordinance does not do that (Sanfilippo v Kull, 2d Dept 2024). The town or village, in turn, cannot be sued over snow, ice or a defect on its sidewalk unless it received written notice of that particular place before the fall and failed to act within a reasonable time, its own work created the hazard, or a special use applies. On private property, such as a store's parking lot, the owner gets a reasonable time after a storm ends to clear it. A claim against a town or village starts with a notice of claim within 90 days, and the lawsuit must be started within one year and 90 days.

The sidewalk usually belongs to the town, not the house next to it

In Hausser v Giunta (1996), the Court of Appeals stated the rule: “Generally, liability for injuries sustained as a result of negligent maintenance of or the existence of dangerous and defective conditions to public sidewalks is placed on the municipality and not the abutting landowner.”

The exceptions are narrow. “An abutting landowner will be liable to a pedestrian injured by a defect in a public sidewalk only when the owner either created the condition or caused the defect to occur because of a special use, or when a statute or ordinance places an obligation to maintain the sidewalk on the owner and expressly makes the owner liable for injuries caused by a breach of that duty” (Kearns v Cedar Cove Dev. Corp., 2022, a Seaford case).

The words that decide many Long Island cases are “expressly makes the owner liable.” The Town of Hempstead Code, § 181-11, tells every owner or occupant to keep the sidewalk in front “free from obstruction by snow or ice and icy conditions.” That is a duty, but not a source of liability to you. In Sanfilippo v Kull (2024), a man slipped on ice on a sidewalk next to a property in the Town of Hempstead, and the Second Department held that the ordinance “does not specifically impose tort liability for a breach of that duty.”

Free Case Review

Tell us what happened — free case review

Prefer to talk? Free Consultation — (516) 750-0595

Other codes go further. In Hausser the Court upheld a City of Long Beach provision making the owner or occupant “liable for any injury or damage by reason of omission, failure or negligence to make, maintain or repair such sidewalk.” New York City’s Administrative Code § 7-210 likewise “provides that said owners are liable for personal injury” caused by a failure to maintain the abutting sidewalk (Rojas v 1388 Bushwick Ave, LLC, 2026). Consequently, the first document to read in a Long Island sidewalk case is the code of the town, village or city where you fell.

When the homeowner or the store can still be liable

The owner who did nothing is generally not liable for snow and ice that fell on a public walk; the owner who made it worse can be. In Roark v Hunting (1969), the Court of Appeals applied the rule that an abutting owner “is not liable even though he fails to comply with a provision of a charter, statute or ordinance charging him with removal of snow and ice,” but is liable where, “by artificial means, snow and ice are transferred from the abutting premises to the sidewalk,” or water from the property is carried onto the walk by artificial means and freezes there.

Shoveling can create liability or defeat it. An owner “may be held liable where it undertakes snow and ice removal efforts which make the naturally occurring conditions more hazardous” (Sanfilippo). The owner there won: her snow removal during the storm did not create or worsen the hazard. The flow below puts those questions in order.

The owner next door

Is the homeowner or the store next to a public sidewalk liable for your fall?

Step 1

Did the owner create the condition or make it worse?

For example, a downspout or drain that carries water onto the walk where it freezes, or shoveling that leaves the walk "more hazardous" than the storm did (Roark v Hunting, 24 NY2d 470 [1969]; Sanfilippo v Kull, 230 AD3d 709 [2d Dept 2024]). Yes, with proof: a claim. No: step 2.

Step 2

Was the sidewalk built or used in a special way for the owner's benefit?

"Where the sidewalk was constructed in a special manner for the benefit of the abutting owner" (Hausser v Giunta, 88 NY2d 449 [1996]). Yes: a claim. No: step 3.

Step 3

Does the local code expressly make the owner liable for injuries?

A duty to shovel is not enough. Town of Hempstead Code § 181-11 imposes the duty but "does not specifically impose tort liability" (Sanfilippo). A provision like the City of Long Beach's in Hausser does. Yes: a claim. No: step 4.

Step 4

Then the claim runs against the municipality

The town, village or city that maintains the sidewalk, subject to its prior written notice law and a notice of claim within 90 days (General Municipal Law § 50-e).

A store facing a public sidewalk stands where the homeowner stands for the walk itself. Its own lot, entrance and steps are different: there the owner “owes a duty of care to maintain his or her property in a reasonably safe condition” (Gronski v County of Monroe, 2011). Where you fell, measured in feet, can change the defendant.

Suing the town or village: written notice of that spot

A town can be sued over a sidewalk it built or maintains, but Town Law § 65-a(2) bars an action for a defect or “in consequence of the existence of snow or ice upon any of its sidewalks” unless “written notice thereof, specifying the particular place, was actually given to the town clerk or to the town superintendent of highways,” and the town then failed to fix it within a reasonable time. Village Law § 6-628 sets the same kind of rule for villages, with notice to the village clerk.

The Town of Hempstead has tightened it by local law. Chapter 6 of its code requires the written notice to be “actually served upon the Town Clerk or Town Commissioner of Highways,” and § 6-4 adds that it “must be made by the witness to the condition” and “must identify, with particularity, the specific nature and location” of the problem. In Sanfilippo, the town won on one affidavit from its Highway Department showing no prior written notice of the ice.

Constructive notice does not get around it. In Amabile v City of Buffalo (1999), the Court of Appeals held that “constructive notice of a defect may not override the statutory requirement of prior written notice,” even where a city worker had driven past or near the spot many times. Nor is the notice of claim you file afterward a substitute; General Municipal Law § 50-e(4) keeps the prior-notice requirement in place. Against a town, the case usually turns on a record in the clerk’s office, not on how long the ice sat there.

Two Second Department decisions of October 28, 2026 show how strictly the rule is read. In Matos-Matos v City of Yonkers, 2026 NY Slip Op 06293 (2d Dept October 28, 2026), a woman tripped over a plank of wood bordering a sidewalk tree well. Yonkers had no prior written notice, she offered no evidence that a dangerous condition arose immediately from the plank’s installation or the city’s 2017 tree removal, and her case against the city was dismissed. In Melendez v City of New York, 2026 NY Slip Op 06294 (2d Dept October 28, 2026), a Big Apple map, the notice system of the state trial lawyers’ association, did not give the city written notice of a hole in a Ridgewood crosswalk, because the “dotted line” relied on matched no defect symbol in the map’s key. A private owner is held to ordinary notice instead: in Velasquez v 88 Cypress, LLC, 2026 NY Slip Op 06346 (2d Dept October 28, 2026), a Queens County case, the owner lost its motion over a loose brick paver on the sidewalk in front of its property because it had not shown the defect was trivial or that it lacked constructive notice.

Two exceptions: the town made the ice, or used the walk for itself

The Court of Appeals recognizes “only two exceptions” to a prior written notice law: “where the locality created the defect or hazard through an affirmative act of negligence and where a ‘special use’ confers a special benefit upon the locality” (Amabile).

For broken pavement the first exception is narrow. It “is limited to work by the City that immediately results in the existence of a dangerous condition” (Oboler v City of New York, 2007; Yarborough v City of New York, 2008), so a pothole patch that wore down over time did not qualify.

Ice is treated differently. In San Marco v Village/Town of Mount Kisco (2010), a woman slipped on black ice in a municipal parking lot that, she alleged, formed when snow the village had plowed against the parking meters melted and refroze. The Court held that “the immediacy requirement for ‘pothole cases’ should not be extended to cases involving hazards related to negligent snow removal,” and left it to a jury whether the village’s snow clearance created the ice. Where a town plow piled the snow that melted and froze, the lack of written notice may not end the case.

Private property: stores, parking lots and the storm in progress

Off the public sidewalk the question is ordinary negligence, with a winter rule on top. “A property owner will not be held liable in negligence for a plaintiff’s injuries sustained as the result of an icy condition occurring during an ongoing storm or for a reasonable time thereafter” (Solazzo v New York City Tr. Auth., 2005).

The defense is limited to the storm itself. In Walker v Jonis Holdings II, LLC (December 17, 2025), a Nassau County case, the plaintiff slipped on ice on a stairway while snow was falling. The owners and their snow contractors won in the trial court and lost on appeal, because they did not show the ice “resulted solely from the ongoing storm, as opposed to prior snowfalls.”

The plowing company is usually not your defendant. In Espinal v Melville Snow Contractors (2002), a worker who slipped in her employer’s icy parking lot had no claim against the company hired to plow it. The card below puts the three possible defendants side by side.

Side by side

Who is liable for a fall on ice or a broken sidewalk on Long Island

Homeowner or store next to a public sidewalk

Generally not liable

  • Rule: public sidewalk liability "is placed on the municipality and not the abutting landowner" (Hausser v Giunta, 88 NY2d 449 [1996]).
  • Unless: it created the condition, made a special use, or a code expressly makes it liable for injuries (Kearns v Cedar Cove Dev. Corp., 208 AD3d 466 [2d Dept 2022]).
  • Ice: liable where water or snow reaches the walk "by artificial means," or its shoveling made the condition "more hazardous" (Roark v Hunting, 24 NY2d 470 [1969]; Sanfilippo v Kull, 230 AD3d 709 [2d Dept 2024]).
  • Town of Hempstead: Code § 181-11 requires clearing but imposes no tort liability (Sanfilippo).

Town, village or city

Liable only after written notice

  • Towns: written notice "specifying the particular place" to the town clerk or highway superintendent (Town Law § 65-a(2)).
  • Villages: written notice "relating to the particular place" to the village clerk (Village Law § 6-628).
  • Town of Hempstead: served on the Town Clerk or Commissioner of Highways, "made by the witness to the condition," with the location "with particularity" (Code §§ 6-3, 6-4).
  • Exceptions: affirmative negligence or special use (Amabile v City of Buffalo, 93 NY2d 471 [1999]); pavement work must "immediately" create the hazard (Yarborough, 10 NY3d 726 [2008]); not required for negligent snow removal (San Marco, 16 NY3d 111 [2010]).

Store or owner on its own property

Liable through control and notice

  • Duty: keep the property "in a reasonably safe condition," premised on control (Gronski v County of Monroe, 18 NY3d 374 [2011]).
  • Storm in progress: not liable during the storm "or for a reasonable time thereafter" (Solazzo, 6 NY3d 734 [2005]).
  • Old ice: summary judgment fails unless the owner shows the ice "resulted solely from the ongoing storm" (Walker v Jonis Holdings II, LLC, 2025 NY Slip Op 07038 [2d Dept]).
  • Snow contractor: no duty to you unless an Espinal exception applies (98 NY2d 136 [2002]).

Deadlines: notice of claim, the 50-h hearing and the lawsuit

Against a town or village, General Municipal Law § 50-e requires a sworn notice of claim served “within ninety days after the claim arises,” and the town may then demand a 50-h hearing before you can sue. The lawsuit must be commenced “within one year and ninety days after the happening of the event.”

You only have 90 days to file a notice of claim against the town or the village. You can’t go wrong with filing a notice of claim. You can go wrong by blowing it. Don’t wait for records from the town, because they may never come. File the notice of claim, and file the lawsuit within one year and 90 days. Whatever the town has, you can ask for in discovery.

Against a homeowner or a store there is no notice of claim, and the deadline is three years under CPLR 214(5).

The clocks

Deadlines after a sidewalk or ice fall, from the day you fell

  1. 90days Notice of claim to the town, village, city or countyGeneral Municipal Law § 50-e(1)(a): sworn, served on the municipality, stating the time, place and manner of the claim. Late notice only by court order (§ 50-e(5)).
  2. 50-hhearing Examination under oath, if the municipality demands oneThe demand must be served within 90 days of filing the notice of claim; no lawsuit until you comply, but if the town does not hold it within 90 days of its demand, you may sue (§ 50-h(2), (5)).
  3. 1 yr 90days Lawsuit against the municipalityGeneral Municipal Law § 50-i(1)(c), at least 30 days after the notice of claim was served and the claim was not paid. The 50-h hearing does not extend it (§ 50-i(3)).
  4. 3years Lawsuit against a homeowner, store or other private ownerCPLR 214(5). No notice of claim.

Who to name, and what to do in the first weeks

On a sidewalk case you sue everybody who could be responsible: the town, the homeowner, the store and whoever plowed. It’s a notice issue. The town is out unless somebody gave it written notice of that particular spot before you fell, or the town created the condition itself. The homeowner is generally out unless the homeowner created the condition or made it worse, or the local code makes owners liable. On its own lot, the store gets a reasonable amount of time after the storm ends to clean up, but that doesn’t apply to old ice from an earlier storm. The facts decide who stays in the case.

That evidence disappears with the next thaw. Photograph the spot before it is salted, with the curb and the buildings on either side in frame. Our posts on ice and black ice crashes and weather-related accident claims apply the same notice rules when the ice is on the road.

Bring these to the first call

After a fall on ice or a broken sidewalk

  1. 1. The exact location and the date and timeThe street address in front of where you fell, the town or village, and whether it was the public walk, a driveway apron, a parking lot or a store entrance.
  2. 2. Your photographsOf the ice or the defect, the downspouts and drains near it, any snow piles, and the curb and property lines.
  3. 3. Your medical recordsThe emergency room or urgent care visit and every treatment after.
  4. 4. Names of witnesses and anyone who had complainedIncluding any neighbor who wrote to the town about that spot before your fall.
  5. 5. Any letter or incident report from a store or its insurerDo not give a recorded statement to an insurer before you have spoken with a lawyer.

Back to the commuter in Wantagh

The homeowner is likely not liable, because the Town of Hempstead’s clearing ordinance does not make owners liable for injuries, unless water from the house’s downspout ran across the walk and froze or the shoveling made it worse. The deli is not liable for a walk it does not face. The town can be liable only if a witness served written notice of that spot before she fell and the town failed to act within a reasonable time, or if a town plow made the ice. Her notice of claim to the town is due within 90 days. Our winter slip and fall guide covers the first 24 hours.

Sources


If you slipped on ice or a broken sidewalk in Nassau or Suffolk, call (516) 750-0595 with the address where you fell and your photographs of the spot, or request a free case review. If a town or village may be responsible, the 90-day notice of claim deadline is already running.

Legal Context

Why This Matters for Your Case

Personal injury law in New York is governed by a complex web of statutes, case law, and procedural rules that differ from most other states. The statute of limitations for most personal injury claims is three years under CPLR 214(5), but claims against municipalities require a Notice of Claim within 90 days. Motor vehicle accident victims must meet the serious injury threshold under Insurance Law §5102(d) before they can recover pain and suffering damages.

The Law Office of Jason Tenenbaum has recovered over $100 million for injured clients across Long Island, Nassau County, Suffolk County, Queens, Brooklyn, Manhattan, and the Bronx. With 24+ years of trial and appellate experience, more than 1,000 appeals written, and 2,600+ published legal articles, Jason Tenenbaum provides the authoritative legal analysis that practitioners and injury victims need to understand their rights.

This article reflects real courtroom experience and a deep understanding of how New York courts actually evaluate personal injury claims — from the initial filing through discovery, summary judgment, trial, and appeal.

Keep Reading

More Slip and Fall Analysis

Legislative Updates

New York Injury and Employment Law in 2026: The Year in Review

The 12 changes to New York injury and employment law from January to November 2026: what changed, when, who it affects, and the primary source for each.

Nov 19, 2026
Car Accidents

Hit in a Long Island Parking Lot: Who Is at Fault, and Can You Sue?

Hit in a Long Island shopping-center lot, in a car or on foot? Which traffic laws apply in a private lot, who is at fault when a car backs out, and when to sue.

Nov 17, 2026
Personal Injury

NY Elbow Injury Car Accident Settlement Values (2026)

Olecranon, radial head & terrible triad elbow fracture settlement values in NY car accidents. §5102(d) threshold, nerve injury analysis. Call 516-750-0595.

Apr 4, 2025
Premises Liability

When Trip and Fall Verdicts Get Overturned: NY Actionable Defects Guide

Learn why a $650K trip and fall verdict was overturned in Rambarran case. Expert analysis of actionable defects in NY premises liability. Call 516-750-0595.

Jan 28, 2019
Personal Injury

The First Federal Social Media Bellwether Trial Was Set for June 15, 2026 — Then Every Defendant Settled: What It Means for New York Families and School Districts

MDL 3047's first federal bellwether trial was set for June 15, 2026 — then settled for a reported $27M. What the K.G.M. verdict and settlements mean for NY.

Jun 12, 2026
Personal Injury

Rear-End Car Accident Settlement in New York: What Is Your Case Worth?

Rear-end accident settlements in New York range from $15,000 to $500,000+.

Apr 3, 2026
View all Slip and Fall articles

Frequently Asked Questions

Common Questions About This Topic

5 answers from the firm's New York personal-injury and employment-law practice. Click any question to expand.

Is a homeowner responsible if someone slips on the icy sidewalk in front of their house in New York?

Generally no, outside New York City. Liability for a public sidewalk rests on the municipality unless the owner created the icy condition (for example, a downspout draining onto the walk), made it worse by shoveling, made a special use of the sidewalk, or a local law expressly makes owners liable for injuries.

Can I sue the town on Long Island for an icy sidewalk?

Only in limited cases. Town Law § 65-a(2) and codes such as the Town of Hempstead's require written notice of the particular place before the fall and a failure to fix it within a reasonable time, unless the town's own work, such as plowing, created the ice, or a special use applies.

What is the storm in progress rule in New York?

An owner is not liable for ice that forms during an ongoing storm, or for a reasonable time after it ends. It does not cover ice left from an earlier storm.

How long do I have to file a claim for a fall on a town sidewalk in Nassau or Suffolk?

90 days to serve a notice of claim on the town or village, and one year and 90 days to start the lawsuit. Against a store or homeowner the deadline is three years.

Is a store liable if I slip on ice in its parking lot?

It can be. A store owes a duty to keep property it controls reasonably safe, subject to the storm in progress rule above. Its snow removal company is usually not liable to you directly.

Was this article helpful?

Disclaimer: This article is published by the Law Office of Jason Tenenbaum, P.C. for informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this content. The legal principles discussed may not apply to your specific situation, and the law may have changed since this article was last updated.

New York law varies by jurisdiction — court decisions in one Appellate Division department may not be followed in another, and local court rules in Nassau County Supreme Court differ from those in Suffolk County Supreme Court, Kings County Civil Court, or Queens County Supreme Court. The Appellate Division, Second Department (which covers Long Island, Brooklyn, Queens, and Staten Island) and the Appellate Term (which hears appeals from lower courts) each have distinct procedural requirements and precedents that affect litigation strategy.

If you need legal help with a slip and fall matter, contact our office at (516) 750-0595 for a free consultation. We serve clients throughout Long Island (Huntington, Babylon, Islip, Brookhaven, Smithtown, Riverhead, Southampton, East Hampton), Nassau County (Hempstead, Garden City, Mineola, Great Neck, Manhasset, Freeport, Long Beach, Rockville Centre, Valley Stream, Westbury, Hicksville, Massapequa), Suffolk County (Hauppauge, Deer Park, Bay Shore, Central Islip, Patchogue, Brentwood), Queens, Brooklyn, Manhattan, the Bronx, Staten Island, and Westchester County. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.

Part of the Premises Liability & Other Injury Claims archive in the Personal Injury Law section of the New York Legal Encyclopedia.

Jason Tenenbaum, Personal Injury Attorney serving Long Island, Nassau County and Suffolk County

Written By

Jason Tenenbaum, Esq.

Jason Tenenbaum is a personal injury attorney serving Long Island, Nassau & Suffolk Counties, and New York City. Admitted to practice in NY, NJ, FL, TX, GA, MI, and Federal courts, Jason is one of the few attorneys who writes his own appeals and tries his own cases. Since 2008, he has authored more than 2,600 articles on no-fault insurance law, personal injury, and employment law — a resource other attorneys rely on to stay current on New York appellate decisions.

Education
Syracuse University College of Law
Experience
24+ Years
Articles
2,600+ Published
Licensed In
6 States + Federal

Free Consultation — No Upfront Fees

Injured on Long Island?
We Fight for What You Deserve.

Serving Nassau County, Suffolk County, and all of New York City. You pay nothing unless we win.

Attorney Jason Tenenbaum has been fighting for the rights of injured New Yorkers since 2002. With over 24 years of experience handling personal injury, no-fault insurance, employment discrimination, and workers' compensation cases, Jason Tenenbaum brings the legal knowledge and courtroom experience your case demands. Every consultation is free and confidential, and we work on a contingency fee basis — meaning you pay absolutely nothing unless we recover compensation for you.

Available 24/7  ·  No fees unless you win  ·  Serving Long Island & NYC

Injured? Don't Wait.

Get Your Free Case Review Today

No fees unless we win — available 24/7 for emergencies.

Free Consultation Free Case Review