Key Takeaway
Signed a waiver at a New York gym, fitness class, trampoline park or pool? General Obligations Law 5-326 voids many. When it applies, and what defenses remain.
This article is part of our ongoing premises liability coverage, with 17 published articles analyzing premises liability issues across New York State. Attorney Jason Tenenbaum brings 24+ years of hands-on experience to this analysis, drawing from his work on more than 1,000 appeals, over 100,000 no-fault cases, and recovery of over $100 million for clients throughout Nassau County, Suffolk County, Queens, Brooklyn, Manhattan, and the Bronx. For personalized legal advice about how these principles apply to your specific situation, contact our Long Island office at (516) 750-0595 for a free consultation.
Almost every gym, fitness studio, trampoline park and swim club on Long Island hands you a release before you can use the place. Most people who get hurt afterward assume the signature ended their case. In New York that is often wrong: a statute written for these businesses makes many of those releases void.
Take an invented example. A Massapequa resident buys a monthly gym membership and signs a membership agreement with a release on the back. Months later, during a free session with one of the gym’s trainers, the cable on a pulley machine snaps and tears the member’s shoulder. Our premises liability practice handles claims against the owners and operators of places like this; this post covers the release and the defenses that come after it.
The short version
Under General Obligations Law § 5-326, a release that exempts the owner or operator of a pool, gymnasium, place of amusement or recreation, or similar establishment from liability for its own negligence is "void as against public policy and wholly unenforceable" when the owner or operator receives a fee for the use of the facility. The courts have read two limits into it. The fee must be for the use of the facility, paid by the user; and a place of instruction, where you pay tuition for lessons, is outside the statute. A gym that offers personal training as a sideline is still a gym. Where the statute does not apply, a release that clearly covers the operator's negligence can end the case. Even with no valid release, you accept the risks inherent in the activity you chose, but not a broken machine or a risk the operator concealed or unreasonably increased. The lawsuit against a private business must be started within three years; a town or county facility needs a notice of claim within 90 days.
What the waiver statute says
The Legislature enacted General Obligations Law § 5-326 in 1976 as a consumer protection measure. The Third Department has described its purpose as stopping amusement parks and recreational facilities from enforcing exculpatory clauses on admission tickets or membership applications “because the public is either unaware of them or not cognizant of their effect.” It reaches any agreement “in or in connection with, or collateral to, any contract, membership application, ticket of admission or similar writing.”
It has four working parts. The defendant owns or operates a pool, gymnasium, place of amusement or recreation, or similar establishment. You are a user of the facility. The operator receives “a fee or other compensation for the use of such facilities.” And the release excuses its own negligence or that of its “agents, servants or employees.” When all four are present, the release is no defense to a claim that the business was negligent.
Free Case Review
Tell us what happened — free case review
Time-sensitive: NY injury claims have strict deadlines
Details received. The fastest next step is a call.
Injury cases are won early. Evidence fades, witnesses move, and New York's no-fault rules can require paperwork within 30 days of a crash. Don't wait for a callback. Call now and a real person takes your information: our office during business hours, and our intake line after hours and on weekends, answered 24/7.
Call (631) 349-3928Free Consultation · Nothing is filed or shared until you decide
Can't call right now? We'll reach out during business hours.
So you signed a waiver at a gym, a pool, a trampoline park. A lot of people think that the waiver ends the case. That’s often not true. New York law, General Obligations Law section 5-326. A waiver of the owner’s negligence is void if you are at a gym, a pool or other place of recreation and you paid a fee to use it. So first question I ask is, what did you pay for? Did you pay for the use of the premises, a membership, a day pass, jump time? Or lessons?
At a glance
When a New York gym or recreation waiver is void: General Obligations Law § 5-326
- What it voids
- Any agreement in or collateral to a "contract, membership application, ticket of admission or similar writing" that exempts the owner or operator from liability for damages caused by the negligence of the owner, operator, person in charge, or "their agents, servants or employees." Result: "void as against public policy and wholly unenforceable."
- Which businesses
- The owner or operator of "any pool, gymnasium, place of amusement or recreation, or similar establishment." A mechanical bull in a bar was one (Meier v Ma-Do Bars, 106 AD2d 143 [3d Dept 1985]); so was a spa with a gym, pool and personal training (Debell v Wellbridge Club Mgt., 40 AD3d 248 [1st Dept 2007]).
- The fee
- "A fee or other compensation for the use of such facilities," paid by the injured user. Not met where only the team's sponsor paid (Stuhlweissenburg v Town of Orangetown, 223 AD2d 633 [2d Dept 1996]) or where a race entry fee bought participation on a public road (Brookner v New York Roadrunners Club, 51 AD3d 841 [2d Dept 2008]).
- The instruction exception
- Not a statutory word; the courts' reading. Tuition for a course at a place used for instruction is not a use fee (Baschuk v Diver's Way Scuba, 209 AD2d 369 [2d Dept 1994], Suffolk County; Millan v Brown, 295 AD2d 409 [2d Dept 2002], Nassau County). Where instruction is "ancillary" to a recreational facility, the statute applies even to an injury during a lesson (Bacchiocchi, 273 AD2d 173 [1st Dept 2000]; Debell).
- How courts decide which it is
- "The organization's name, its certificate of incorporation, its statement of purpose and whether the money it charges is tuition or a fee for use of the facility" (Lemoine v Cornell Univ., 2 AD3d 1017 [3d Dept 2003]). Conflicting proof is a question of fact (Fusco v Now & Zen, 294 AD2d 466 [2d Dept 2002]).
- If the statute does not apply
- The release still has to say, clearly, that it covers the operator's own negligence; a release with that "clarity, precision, and specificity" is enforced (Baschuk). A complaint that pleads facts amounting to gross negligence is analyzed separately (Lemoine).
The fee: what you paid, and who you paid
The fee requirement does a lot of work. In Stuhlweissenburg v Town of Orangetown, a softball player was hurt sliding into third base on a town field. Her team’s sponsor allegedly paid the town $400, but there was “no proof whatsoever” that she paid anything, and the Second Department held that “the individual must have paid a fee for use of the facility.” Her release stood. In Brookner v New York Roadrunners Club, a marathon runner’s entry fee paid for his participation, “not an admission fee allowing him to use the City-owned public roadway,” and his release barred the claim too.
A gym membership, a day pass, a pool admission and a block of jump time are each money paid to the operator for the use of its facility. None of the decisions discussed here involves a trampoline park, so the analysis there starts with the statute’s words, and on those words a business that sells jump time is a place of recreation that takes a fee for the use of its facility. Consequently, the first document in any of these cases is the receipt or the app record that shows what you paid and to whom.
Instruction or recreation: the line the courts drew
The statute says nothing about lessons. The exception comes from the cases, and two of them came out of Long Island courts. In Baschuk v Diver’s Way Scuba, a Suffolk County case, a woman paid tuition for a scuba course taught in the defendant’s private pool and punctured an eardrum during the fourth session. The Second Department held that the pool “was used for instructional, not recreational or amusement, purposes,” that tuition “is not analogous to the use fee,” and enforced her release. In Millan v Brown, from Nassau County, a rider who paid a $30 instruction fee directly to the instructor was hurt during the lesson, and the riding establishment was not a “place of amusement or recreation.”
The decision flow below sets out how the courts apply the statute and its exception, step by step.
Does the waiver hold?
Four questions about a release signed at a New York gym, class, pool or park
Step 1
Did you pay the operator to use the facility?
Membership, day pass, admission, jump time. Yes: go to step 2. No (free entry, a sponsor paid, a race entry on a public road): § 5-326 does not apply; go to step 4.
Step 2
Is it a pool, gym, place of amusement or recreation, or similar?
Yes: go to step 3. No: go to step 4.
Step 3
Is the place recreational, with any instruction a sideline?
Courts look at the name, the certificate of incorporation, the stated purpose and tuition versus use fee. Recreational: the release is void as to the operator's negligence, even for an injury during a lesson. Instructional (you paid tuition for a course): go to step 4.
Step 4
Does the release clearly cover the operator's own negligence?
Yes: it can bar a claim of ordinary negligence. No: it does not bar that claim. Either way, the assumption of risk analysis comes next.
In gym cases the third step usually decides it. In Debell v Wellbridge Club Management, a spa member tore a rotator cuff during a complimentary session with a trainer who allegedly insisted on a hang-bar exercise despite the member’s complaints of pain. The trial court enforced the release because the injury happened during instruction. The First Department reversed: the focus “should have been on whether the Spa’s purpose was recreational or instructional,” and a spa that sold access to equipment, a pool, a sauna and beauty services, with four free training sessions, offered training as an “ancillary” service. The release was void.
A studio that sells only classes is a closer case. In Fusco v Now & Zen, a karate school said it was instructional, attendees testified they used it for recreation, and the Second Department sent the question to trial, noting the record lacked the certificate of incorporation and the method of payment. A spin, yoga or boxing studio that sells class packs will make the same argument.
Back in Massapequa, the member paid a monthly fee to use a gym, and the training session was a free extra. On the reasoning of Debell, the release does not protect the gym from its own negligence.
When a waiver still counts
When the statute does not reach the release, a court reads it, and it is enforced only if it clearly covers the operator’s own negligence. In Baschuk the release was written “in clear and unequivocal language,” and that “clarity, precision, and specificity” made it enforceable. The word negligence need not appear: in Debell, a release of claims “whether or not based on the acts or omissions of the Spa” was held to “convey[] a similar import.” The First Department in Bacchiocchi described the Court of Appeals’ decision in Gross v Sweet (1979) as turning on a clause inadequate to convey “to prospective students that they would have to abide any consequences attributable to the instructor’s own carelessness.”
In Lemoine v Cornell University, a student fell from a climbing wall during a tuition-paid course. The release was valid, and the Third Department went on to ask whether the complaint alleged gross negligence, “reckless conduct that borders on intentional wrongdoing”; it alleged only ordinary negligence, and the case was dismissed. Consequently, a valid release is a serious defense, but it is read word by word, and reckless conduct is a separate question.
Assumption of risk: the defense that comes next
A void release does not decide the case. The gym’s next argument is primary assumption of risk. New York abolished assumption of risk as a complete defense in 1975, but the Court of Appeals kept a narrow version for sports and recreation, a “principle of no duty” whose application “must be closely circumscribed” (Trupia v Lake George Cent. School Dist., 2010), generally limited to sporting events, sponsored activities and “athletic and recreational pursuits that take place at designated venues” (Custodi v Town of Amherst, 2012). Expect a gym, a studio or a trampoline park to argue it is that kind of venue.
Where the doctrine applies, a person who chooses to take part “consents to certain risks that are inherent in and arise out of the nature of the sport generally and flow from such participation.” On March 18, 2026, the Second Department applied that rule to a child who fell from a scooter at a Riverhead skate park: “Falling is a risk inherent in riding a scooter” (T.A. v Town of Riverhead).
Two of the cases decided with Morgan v State of New York (1997) came out of martial arts classes. In Beck v Scimeca, a student at a Long Island karate academy hurt his spine on a jump roll over an obstacle that a 15-year-old student left in charge had raised; he assumed the risk of landing wrong. In Chimerine, a student in her fourth tae kwon do class hurt her knee on a jumping kick, and she too assumed the risk.
So in assuming the risks of doing an activity, you’re assuming the risks which are inherent to the act or the sport itself. So if you fall when you jump, land wrong, those are things that you assume as a risk. But that does not necessarily include a broken machine, a frayed cable, a torn net. That can be maintenance.
The limit is in the same decision. In Siegel v City of New York, a member of a Brooklyn tennis club tripped on a torn vinyl hem at the bottom of a divider net he had known about for two years. The Court reinstated his case: “a torn net is not an ‘inherent’ part of the game of tennis,” but a maintenance condition. Nor do participants assume “concealed or unreasonably increased risks.” Consequently, the claims that survive are about the condition of the facility and the conduct of the people who run it.
Equipment, maintenance and supervision claims
The comparison below sorts the injuries these cases produce into the two piles the courts use.
Usually assumed
Risks inherent in the activity
- Falling or landing wrong while performing the move you chose (T.A. v Town of Riverhead, 2d Dept 2026; Beck, 1997).
- Losing balance on a hopping or jumping kick in a class (Chimerine, 1997).
- A risk you were aware of in kind, even if not the exact way it happened: awareness of "the potential for injury of the mechanism" is enough (Grady v Chenango Val. Cent. Sch. Dist., 40 NY3d 89 [2023], as quoted in T.A.).
- "Less than optimal conditions" that come with the sport, such as an irregular outdoor court (Bukowski v Clarkson Univ., 19 NY3d 353 [2012]).
Not assumed
Claims that can go forward
- A worn, torn or broken piece of equipment or facility, a maintenance condition (Siegel, torn tennis net, 1997).
- "Concealed or unreasonably increased risks" (Morgan, 90 NY2d 471, 485 [1997]).
- Reckless or intentional conduct (Morgan).
- Activity outside a sport or a designated venue, where the doctrine does not apply at all (Custodi, 20 NY3d 83 [2012]).
- Your own share of fault reduces the award; it does not bar it (CPLR 1411(a)).
A personal trainer’s negligence fits the second column when the trainer creates a risk the client did not take on. The statute voids a release of the operator’s liability for its “agents, servants or employees,” which reaches a trainer on the gym’s staff. Debell alleged the familiar version, a trainer who insists on an exercise after the client says it hurts; the court decided only the release question, and negligence was left to be proved.
Supervision is harder. In Beck, a capable senior student placed temporarily in charge of routine exercises was not, standing alone, enough for a trial. An empty lifeguard chair or an unstaffed trampoline court are different facts, and each turns on proof.
Deadlines, and what to do now
A personal injury action against a private gym, studio, park or pool must be commenced within three years (CPLR 214(5)). A pool, rink or recreation center run by a town, a county or a village needs a notice of claim within 90 days and a lawsuit within one year and 90 days (General Municipal Law § 50-e and § 50-i). A child’s own claim gets the infancy extension in CPLR 208; our page on the personal injury statute of limitations in New York covers the rules. Do not plan around an extension.
So these are things that you want to do in the first couple days. Take a photograph of the machine, the mat, the trampoline, the wet floor, before somebody comes and fixes it, or they clean it up. Ask for an incident report. Get the names of the staff and the trainer on duty. Keep the membership agreement, the waiver, the receipt or your app record of what you paid. Bring all of that to your first call.
Bring these to the first call
After an injury at a gym, class, pool or trampoline park
- 1. The waiver or membership agreement you signedAsk the business for a copy if you signed on a tablet or an app.
- 2. Proof of what you paid and to whomMembership statement, day pass, class pack, jump-time receipt or the card charge. The fee decides whether the statute applies.
- 3. Photos of the machine, mat, net, trampoline or floorTaken before it is repaired or replaced.
- 4. The incident report and the names of staff on dutyIncluding the trainer, instructor or lifeguard, and any other member who saw it.
- 5. Your medical records from the first visit onUrgent care, emergency room and every follow-up.
For the member in Massapequa, the analysis runs in order. The release is void as to the gym’s negligence, because the member paid to use a gym and the training was a sideline. A snapped cable is a maintenance condition, not a risk inherent in lifting. The case is negligence against the gym, started within three years. For pools in particular, our post on Long Island pool accident liability covers municipal pools, barrier rules and drowning injuries.
Sources
- General Obligations Law § 5-326
- Debell v Wellbridge Club Mgt., Inc., 40 AD3d 248 (1st Dept 2007)
- Baschuk v Diver’s Way Scuba, Inc., 209 AD2d 369 (2d Dept 1994)
- Millan v Brown, 295 AD2d 409 (2d Dept 2002)
- Fusco v Now & Zen, Inc., 294 AD2d 466 (2d Dept 2002)
- Stuhlweissenburg v Town of Orangetown, 223 AD2d 633 (2d Dept 1996)
- Brookner v New York Roadrunners Club, Inc., 51 AD3d 841 (2d Dept 2008)
- Lemoine v Cornell Univ., 2 AD3d 1017 (3d Dept 2003)
- Bacchiocchi v Ranch Parachute Club, 273 AD2d 173 (1st Dept 2000)
- Meier v Ma-Do Bars, 106 AD2d 143 (3d Dept 1985)
- Bukowski v Clarkson Univ., 19 NY3d 353 (2012)
- Morgan v State of New York, 90 NY2d 471 (1997)
- Trupia v Lake George Cent. School Dist., 14 NY3d 392 (2010)
- Custodi v Town of Amherst, 20 NY3d 83 (2012)
- T.A. v Town of Riverhead, 2026 NY Slip Op 01480 (2d Dept March 18, 2026)
- CPLR 214, CPLR 208 and CPLR 1411
- General Municipal Law § 50-e and § 50-i
If you were hurt at a gym, fitness class, trampoline park or pool on Long Island after signing a waiver, call (516) 750-0595 with the membership agreement or receipt in hand, or request a free case review.
Legal Context
Why This Matters for Your Case
Personal injury law in New York is governed by a complex web of statutes, case law, and procedural rules that differ from most other states. The statute of limitations for most personal injury claims is three years under CPLR 214(5), but claims against municipalities require a Notice of Claim within 90 days. Motor vehicle accident victims must meet the serious injury threshold under Insurance Law §5102(d) before they can recover pain and suffering damages.
The Law Office of Jason Tenenbaum has recovered over $100 million for injured clients across Long Island, Nassau County, Suffolk County, Queens, Brooklyn, Manhattan, and the Bronx. With 24+ years of trial and appellate experience, more than 1,000 appeals written, and 2,600+ published legal articles, Jason Tenenbaum provides the authoritative legal analysis that practitioners and injury victims need to understand their rights.
This article reflects real courtroom experience and a deep understanding of how New York courts actually evaluate personal injury claims — from the initial filing through discovery, summary judgment, trial, and appeal.
Keep Reading
More Premises Liability Analysis
Can a Police Officer or Firefighter Sue After Being Hurt on the Job in New York?
New York abolished most of the firefighter rule. How General Obligations Law § 11-106 and General Municipal Law § 205-a and § 205-e let injured officers sue.
Nov 12, 2026Child Hurt in School Gym Class or Sports in New York: When Is the School Liable?
Child hurt in gym class or school sports in New York? When a school is liable for poor supervision, how assumption of risk works, and the 90-day notice.
Nov 9, 2026Heat Stroke at Work in New York? You May Have a Claim
New York workers injured by heat stroke on construction sites or outdoor jobs may be entitled to compensation beyond workers' comp. Know your rights.
Jul 6, 2026Rollover Accident Settlement in New York: What Your Case Is Worth
Rollover accidents on Long Island can involve multiple defendants — other drivers, vehicle manufacturers, and tire companies.
Apr 4, 2026NYC Boat Accidents
NYC boat accident lawyers explain maritime law complexities, federal vs state jurisdiction, safety violations, and legal deadlines for injury claims in New York waters.
May 9, 2025Mastering Medical Expenses in Personal Injury Claims
A practical New York injury-bill checklist: identify the payer, track bills and denials, document future care, and review repayment demands before settlement.
Dec 10, 2024Frequently Asked Questions
Common Questions About This Topic
5 answers from the firm's New York personal-injury and employment-law practice. Click any question to expand.
Can I sue a gym if I signed a waiver in New York?
Often, yes. General Obligations Law § 5-326 voids a release that excuses a gym, pool or place of recreation from its own negligence when you paid a fee to use the facility. You still have to prove negligence, and the gym can still argue you assumed the risks inherent in the activity.
Does a waiver protect a trampoline park in New York?
On the statute's words, a park that charges for jump time is a place of recreation that receives a fee for the use of its facility, so a release of its own negligence falls within § 5-326. The park can still argue that a bad landing is a risk inherent in jumping. A broken spring or a torn mat is a maintenance claim.
Is a waiver for a fitness class or personal training session enforceable?
It depends on the business. Where a gym is recreational and the training is an add-on, the statute voids the release even for an injury during training (*Debell*, 1st Dept 2007). Where you paid tuition for a course at a place used for instruction, courts have enforced clear releases (*Baschuk*, 2d Dept 1994).
I was hurt at a town pool on Long Island. Is the deadline different?
Yes. A facility run by a town, a county or a village in Nassau or Suffolk requires a notice of claim within 90 days and a lawsuit within one year and 90 days. Against a private club or business, the deadline is three years.
Does assumption of risk apply to gym injuries in New York?
It can. It covers risks inherent in the activity, such as landing a jump or a move wrong. It does not cover a torn or broken piece of equipment, or risks the operator concealed or unreasonably increased.
Was this article helpful?
Disclaimer: This article is published by the Law Office of Jason Tenenbaum, P.C. for informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, and no attorney-client relationship is formed by reading this content. The legal principles discussed may not apply to your specific situation, and the law may have changed since this article was last updated.
New York law varies by jurisdiction — court decisions in one Appellate Division department may not be followed in another, and local court rules in Nassau County Supreme Court differ from those in Suffolk County Supreme Court, Kings County Civil Court, or Queens County Supreme Court. The Appellate Division, Second Department (which covers Long Island, Brooklyn, Queens, and Staten Island) and the Appellate Term (which hears appeals from lower courts) each have distinct procedural requirements and precedents that affect litigation strategy.
If you need legal help with a premises liability matter, contact our office at (516) 750-0595 for a free consultation. We serve clients throughout Long Island (Huntington, Babylon, Islip, Brookhaven, Smithtown, Riverhead, Southampton, East Hampton), Nassau County (Hempstead, Garden City, Mineola, Great Neck, Manhasset, Freeport, Long Beach, Rockville Centre, Valley Stream, Westbury, Hicksville, Massapequa), Suffolk County (Hauppauge, Deer Park, Bay Shore, Central Islip, Patchogue, Brentwood), Queens, Brooklyn, Manhattan, the Bronx, Staten Island, and Westchester County. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.