Defense expert states that injury aggravated pre-existing condition – yet jury verdict dismissing claim affirmed

If you were injured due to someone else’s careless actions, we understand the challenges you may be facing. As a victim or a surviving family member, you could be dealing with the life-altering consequences of a serious accident.

Doran v McNulty, 2013 NY Slip Op 04572 (2d Dept. 2013)

“At the damages trial the plaintiff testified that she had experienced, and been treated for, pain in her lower back since she was 16 years old, but the pain had become more intense and constant after the accident.”

 

[EXPERT #1] The plaintiff’s expert testified that the fall had aggravated the plaintiff’s preexisting condition.

[EXPERT #2] For the defense, a radiologist who reviewed the MRI films of the plaintiff’s back taken after the accident testified that the plaintiff’s condition could not have been caused by an acute event such as a fall, and was instead the result of the plaintiff’s preexisting degenerative disc disease.

[EXPERT #3] An orthopedic surgeon called by the defendants testified that the accident aggravated the preexisting degenerative changes in the plaintiff’s back, but that the plaintiff had “no radicular symptoms” as a result of the accident. The jury awarded the plaintiff no damages.”

Here, a fair interpretation of the evidence supported the jury’s determination (see Verizon N.Y., Inc. v Orange & Rockland Utils., Inc., 100 AD3d 983Piazza v Corporate Bldrs. Group, Inc., 73 AD3d at 1006-1007; Salony v Mastellone, 72 AD3d at 1061). While the plaintiff correctly notes that the orthopedic surgeon called by the defendants testified that the subject accident aggravated the preexisting degenerative changes in the plaintiff’s back, in light of the conflicting expert testimony at trial, the jury could accept or reject the testimony of a particular expert”

Does this make sense?  My vote is no.  Furthermore, this is not a threshold case.   Plaintiff should be awarded something.

Facebook
Twitter
Email
Print

Latest Article

DON'T ACCEPT LESS THAN WHAT YOU'RE OWED!

Choosing the right legal representation is one of the most critical decisions you can make after an accident.

Partnering with a skilled, experienced, and dedicated personal injury attorney can bolster your case and position you to secure the full financial compensation you’re entitled to.

Our firm is ready to manage every aspect of your case, including negotiations with insurance companies. We reject inadequate settlement offers and relentlessly fight for the maximum compensation you rightfully deserve.

Contact Us – We’re Here to Help


    5-Star Rating on Google