Hit and Run Accident Settlement in New York: Your Rights When the Driver Flees

Being struck by a driver who then speeds away is one of the most disorienting things that can happen on Long Island roads. In a matter of seconds, you go from a routine trip to a medical emergency — and the person responsible has vanished. Hit and run accidents happen with alarming frequency on Long Island and throughout New York State. The New York State Department of Motor Vehicles consistently records tens of thousands of hit and run incidents each year.

What makes these cases especially difficult is the layered uncertainty: you may not know who hit you, whether they have insurance, or whether your own policy will cover what happened. The clock also starts running immediately on several critical deadlines that can permanently affect your right to recover.

The good news is that New York law provides multiple pathways to compensation even when the at-fault driver is never identified. This article explains how those pathways work, what your case may realistically be worth, and what steps you need to take — starting today.

---

Three Recovery Pathways After a Hit and Run

Your options depend almost entirely on whether the driver is eventually identified. Here is how the three scenarios play out.

1. The Driver Is Later Identified

If police locate the driver — through witness statements, surveillance footage, license plate readers, or the driver’s own conscience — your case becomes a standard New York car accident claim. You can pursue a lawsuit against the driver personally and a claim against their liability insurer. No-fault benefits still apply. The full range of damages under New York Insurance Law §5102(d) is available, including lost earnings and pain and suffering if you meet the serious injury threshold.

2. The Driver Is Never Found — Uninsured Motorist (UM) Coverage

When the driver remains unidentified, you turn to your own auto insurance policy. New York law requires every private passenger auto policy issued in New York to include uninsured motorist (UM) coverage (NY Insurance Law §3420). This coverage steps in and compensates you as if the at-fault driver had been found and had a minimum-limit policy. Your claim is processed by your own insurer but proceeds to arbitration — not a lawsuit — through the American Arbitration Association (AAA).

3. No Auto Insurance at All — MVAIC

If you have no auto insurance of your own and no resident relative with an auto policy, the Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corporation (MVAIC) is the insurer of last resort. MVAIC is a state-created fund designed to ensure that innocent victims are not left completely without recourse simply because they lacked personal auto coverage. MVAIC claims are subject to strict procedural requirements and statutory caps.

---

Uninsured Motorist Coverage in New York

What New York Law Requires

Every private passenger automobile insurance policy issued in New York must include UM coverage with minimum limits of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident (NY Insurance Law §3420(f)(1)). This is not optional. If you have a New York auto policy, you have at least this coverage.

How to Make a UM Claim After a Hit and Run

Notify your insurer promptly. Most UM endorsements require written notice of the claim within 30 days of the accident. Missing this deadline can give your insurer grounds to disclaim coverage. Send written notice — preferably certified mail — as soon as possible.

The claim goes to arbitration, not court. UM claims in New York are resolved through arbitration under the AAA’s rules for motor vehicle accident disputes, not through the civil court system. This is both a procedural and a strategic distinction: arbitration is generally faster than litigation, discovery is more limited, and the arbitrator’s award is typically final (subject to narrow grounds for appeal under CPLR Article 75).

UM pays like a lawsuit — up to your limits. The UM arbitrator evaluates your claim the same way a jury would: liability, causation, and damages. You can recover the same categories of loss you would recover in a lawsuit, including medical expenses, lost wages, and pain and suffering (assuming you meet the serious injury threshold under Insurance Law §5102(d)). However, your recovery is capped at your UM policy limits — which is why those limits matter.

SUM — Supplementary Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Coverage

New York law also allows insureds to purchase Supplementary Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist (SUM) coverage at limits higher than the statutory minimum. SUM covers both uninsured drivers (including hit and run drivers) and underinsured drivers (those whose liability limits are lower than your SUM limits). If you have SUM coverage, your per-person recovery cap rises to whatever limits you purchased — $100,000, $250,000, $500,000, or more.

If your current policy has only $25,000 in UM/SUM coverage and you sustained serious injuries, that is a hard ceiling. An attorney can help you explore whether other policies — a spouse’s policy, a parent’s policy, a homeowner’s umbrella — provide additional layers of coverage.

---

MVAIC: The Safety Net for Uninsured Victims

What MVAIC Is

The Motor Vehicle Accident Indemnification Corporation (MVAIC) was created by New York statute specifically to compensate innocent victims who have no other source of insurance recovery after being injured by an uninsured or unidentified motorist. Think of it as a state-mandated fund of last resort.

Who Qualifies

To make a MVAIC claim, you must generally be:

• A New York State resident
• Injured in New York State
• Injured by an unidentified (hit and run) or uninsured motor vehicle
• Without your own auto insurance policy AND without a resident relative who has an auto insurance policy

If you live with a spouse or parent who has an auto policy, you likely have UM coverage available through that policy and would not need to go through MVAIC.

The 90-Day Notice Deadline

This is the most dangerous deadline in a MVAIC case. You must notify MVAIC of your claim within 90 days of the accident. This is a strict statutory requirement, and courts have denied claims filed even a few days late. Do not wait. If you believe you may have a MVAIC claim, contact the corporation (or an attorney who can do so on your behalf) immediately.

The Recovery Cap

MVAIC’s maximum payout mirrors the statutory minimum for UM coverage: $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident. These limits have not changed in decades, and they reflect the absolute ceiling regardless of how serious your injuries are. MVAIC is a meaningful safety net, but it is not a path to full compensation for catastrophic injuries.

---

What Is a Hit and Run Under New York Law?

New York Vehicle and Traffic Law §600 makes it a crime to leave the scene of an accident without stopping, identifying yourself, and rendering reasonable assistance to any injured person. The severity of the charge depends on what was damaged:

• Property damage only: Leaving the scene is a misdemeanor under VTL §600(1).
• Personal injury or death: Leaving the scene is a Class D felony under VTL §600(2), carrying up to seven years in prison.

Beyond the criminal exposure, a driver who flees creates a civil record problem for themselves if later found. Evidence of flight can be relevant to the damages phase of a civil case.

A police report is essential. Both your insurer (for a UM claim) and MVAIC will require documentation that the accident involved an unidentified vehicle. Filing a police report promptly — within 24 hours if possible — creates that documentation. It also triggers an official investigation that may turn up the fleeing driver through street cameras, license plate readers, or neighborhood canvasses.

---

The 30-Day No-Fault Application Deadline

New York’s no-fault system (Insurance Law §5102 et seq.) covers medical bills and lost wages regardless of fault — including in hit and run cases. But you must apply within 30 days of the accident.

In a hit and run, you file your no-fault application with:

1. Your own auto insurer (if you have one), or
2. The insurer of the vehicle you were riding in (if you were a passenger), or
3. A resident relative’s auto insurer (if you have no policy of your own)

If none of those options apply, MVAIC can also serve as the no-fault insurer of last resort — but you still must notify MVAIC within the applicable deadlines.

Missing the 30-day no-fault deadline can result in your insurer denying coverage for all medical bills and lost wages, regardless of how serious your injuries are. Courts have occasionally allowed late filings when there is reasonable justification, but do not count on that exception. File on time.

---

What Hit and Run Settlements Are Worth in New York

Settlement and arbitration values in hit and run cases depend heavily on three variables: the severity of your injuries, the amount of insurance coverage available, and whether the driver is eventually identified.

Minor injuries with UM or MVAIC coverage (minimum limits): If your injuries are soft-tissue and largely resolved, and you are limited to the $25,000 MVAIC cap or minimum UM limits, realistic recovery is generally in the range of $10,000 to $25,000 per person. MVAIC cases rarely approach the $25,000 cap unless injuries are significant.

Moderate injuries with higher UM/SUM limits: If you purchased $100,000 or $250,000 in SUM coverage and sustained injuries requiring surgery, extended physical therapy, or resulting in documented permanent limitations, values typically range from $50,000 to $200,000 depending on medical evidence and the strength of your liability case.

Severe or catastrophic injuries with the driver identified or high SUM limits: When the driver is found and carries substantial liability coverage — or when the injured party purchased high SUM limits — recovery in the range of $200,000 to $1 million or more is realistic for cases involving spinal cord injuries, traumatic brain injuries, loss of limb, or other life-altering conditions. These cases require establishing serious injury under Insurance Law §5102(d) and presenting compelling medical evidence of causation and permanency.

Important caveat on MVAIC: No matter how catastrophic the injuries, MVAIC will not pay more than $25,000 per person. If your injuries are severe and the driver is never found, the only way to maximize your recovery is through SUM coverage under your own policy or a family member’s policy. This is why purchasing adequate SUM limits is so important — before an accident happens.

---

Critical Steps to Take After a Hit and Run

The actions you take in the hours and days immediately following a hit and run will directly affect the value and viability of your claim.

1. Call 911 immediately. Report the accident and request medical attention even if you feel fine. Adrenaline masks pain. A contemporaneous EMS record establishes the accident happened and documents initial injuries.

2. Photograph everything at the scene. Capture skid marks, debris fields, the road conditions, any paint transfer on vehicles involved, traffic signs, and your visible injuries. Take wide shots and close-ups.

3. Collect witness information. Bystanders are a disappearing resource. Get names, phone numbers, and license plates of anyone who saw what happened. Ask if anyone has dashcam footage.

4. Note nearby cameras. Look for security cameras on storefronts, ATMs, gas stations, and traffic light housings. Surveillance footage is often overwritten within 24 to 72 hours. Your attorney can send preservation letters immediately.

5. File a police report within 24 hours. If the responding officer does not file a report at the scene, go to the precinct. A police report number is required for UM and MVAIC claims.

6. Notify your insurance company within 30 days. Send written notice of both your no-fault claim and your UM claim. Do not rely on a phone call alone — follow up in writing.

7. Notify MVAIC within 90 days if you are uninsured. If you have no auto insurance and no resident relative with coverage, contact MVAIC directly or retain an attorney who will do so immediately.

8. Retain an attorney quickly. The general statute of limitations for personal injury claims in New York is three years under CPLR §214, but the UM arbitration filing deadline, the no-fault deadline, and the MVAIC notice deadline are all far shorter. An attorney ensures none of these windows close before your claim is protected.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I sue the driver if they are never found?

No — you cannot file a lawsuit against an unknown person. But “suing” is not your only option. A UM claim through your own insurer or a MVAIC claim achieves the same economic result: compensation for your injuries determined through a formal process (UM arbitration or MVAIC proceedings). The practical difference is that your recovery is capped at available policy limits rather than whatever a jury might award.

What if I do not have car insurance?

If you have no auto insurance and no resident relative with an auto policy, MVAIC is your primary avenue for recovery. You must notify MVAIC within 90 days of the accident. Your recovery will be capped at $25,000 per person / $50,000 per accident. If you do have a resident relative with auto insurance — a spouse, a parent, a sibling living in your home — their UM coverage likely extends to you, and you should pursue a UM claim through that policy first.

How does UM arbitration work?

UM arbitrations in New York are administered by the American Arbitration Association (AAA). After you file a demand for arbitration (typically through your attorney), the parties exchange medical records, wage documentation, and other evidence. A neutral arbitrator — usually a retired judge or experienced attorney — conducts a hearing at which your attorney presents your damages case. The arbitrator issues a written award, which is generally final. Arbitration is usually resolved faster than a civil lawsuit, often within 12 to 24 months of filing, depending on case complexity and hearing availability.

Does it matter if I was a pedestrian or cyclist rather than a vehicle occupant?

No — pedestrians and cyclists injured by hit and run drivers are entitled to the same UM and MVAIC protections as vehicle occupants in New York. If you have your own auto policy, your UM coverage applies to you as a pedestrian. If you have no auto insurance, MVAIC covers qualifying pedestrian and cyclist victims. No-fault benefits also extend to pedestrians injured by motor vehicles in New York, so the 30-day no-fault application deadline applies regardless of whether you were on foot or in a car.

What if my UM limits are too low for my injuries?

First, check whether you have SUM coverage at higher limits — many people do not realize they purchased it. Second, if you have no auto insurance, MVAIC provides the statutory minimum. Third, if the driver is later identified and has liability insurance, you may be able to pursue a claim against their policy in addition to your SUM coverage. If none of these options closes the gap, a skilled personal injury attorney can help you identify any umbrella policies or other sources of coverage that may apply — and can work to maximize your recovery within whatever limits exist.

---

Contact the Law Office of Jason Tenenbaum, P.C.

If you or a family member was injured in a hit and run accident on Long Island or anywhere in New York, the window to protect your rights is already open — and several deadlines are counting down right now.

The Law Office of Jason Tenenbaum, P.C. has represented injured New Yorkers in UM arbitrations, MVAIC claims, and car accident litigation for years. We understand the procedural traps in these cases and how to build the strongest possible claim under whatever coverage is available.

Learn more about how we can help:

• Long Island Hit and Run Accident Lawyer
• Long Island Car Accident Lawyer

Contact us today for a free consultation. There is no fee unless we recover for you.

---

This article is intended for general informational purposes and does not constitute legal advice. The law applicable to your specific situation may differ. Consult a qualified New York personal injury attorney regarding your individual circumstances.