Long Island Orbital Fracture
Lawyer
Orbital fractures from a Long Island car accident are per se serious injuries under New York law. Blowout fractures, ZMC tripod fractures, diplopia, enophthalmos, and traumatic optic neuropathy demand experienced legal representation. No fee unless we win.
Serving Long Island, Nassau County, Suffolk County & All of NYC
$100M+
Recovered
24+
Years Experience
$620K
Top Orbital Result
24/7
Available
Quick Answer
Orbital fractures from Long Island car accidents are per se serious injuries under New York Insurance Law §5102(d) — each confirmed fracture independently satisfies the fracture category without separately proving significant limitation. The orbit has four walls: the roof (frontal bone, above which lies the anterior cranial fossa), the floor (maxillary bone — the most fragile wall, only 0.5–1mm thick above the maxillary sinus), the medial wall (paper-thin lamina papyracea of the ethmoid, the thinnest wall), and the lateral wall (zygomatic and sphenoid bones — the strongest). Fracture patterns range from pure blowout fractures (floor or medial wall without rim, from hydraulic or buckling mechanism) to ZMC tripod fractures (zygomatic complex — malar eminence, arch, orbital rim, and floor) to complex NOE and orbital roof fractures with intracranial extension. Critical complications include diplopia from inferior rectus entrapment, enophthalmos from floor defect, infraorbital nerve hypoesthesia, traumatic optic neuropathy, and globe injury. CT orbit with 1mm coronal cuts is the gold standard for diagnosis. Surgical repair with titanium mesh or Medpor implant is indicated for significant enophthalmos, persistent diplopia with entrapment, large defects >50% of floor, or white-eyed blowout in children.
Last updated: April 2026 · Every case is unique — these ranges reflect general New York outcomes and are not guarantees.
Types of Orbital Fractures We Handle
From isolated blowout fractures of the orbital floor to complex ZMC tripod fractures requiring four-point plate fixation, we handle the full spectrum of eye socket injuries from Long Island car accidents.
Pure Blowout Fracture (Floor or Medial Wall — No Rim)
Impure Blowout Fracture (Floor + Rim Involvement)
ZMC / Tripod Fracture (Zygomatic Complex)
Orbital Roof Fracture with Intracranial Extension
NOE Fracture (Nasoorbitoethmoid — Telecanthus, Epiphora)
Titanium Mesh or Medpor Implant Orbital Reconstruction
Orbital Anatomy, Fracture Types, and Car Accident Mechanisms
The orbit is a bony pyramid-shaped cavity housing the eyeball and its associated structures: the six extraocular muscles controlling eye movement, the optic nerve and ophthalmic artery running through the optic canal, the orbital fat pad that maintains globe position and cushions the eye, and the lacrimal drainage system. Understanding orbital wall anatomy is essential for predicting fracture patterns in car accidents and the specific complications associated with each wall.
The Four Orbital Walls: Anatomy and Fracture Vulnerability
The orbital floor is the most commonly fractured wall in motor vehicle accidents because it is the thinnest bony surface in the orbit, measuring only 0.5 to 1mm in the posterior portion above the maxillary sinus. The infraorbital neurovascular bundle — containing the infraorbital nerve (a branch of V2, the maxillary division of the trigeminal nerve) and infraorbital vessels — runs in a groove and then a canal through the orbital floor before exiting at the infraorbital foramen below the rim. Fractures of the orbital floor frequently injure this nerve, producing the classic clinical finding of cheek and upper lip numbness (infraorbital hypoesthesia) ipsilateral to the injury. Below the orbital floor lies the maxillary sinus, into which orbital fat, the inferior rectus muscle, or the inferior oblique muscle may herniate when the floor fractures.
The medial wall is formed primarily by the lamina papyracea of the ethmoid bone — literally "paper wall" in Latin — which is among the thinnest bones in the human body, measuring less than 0.5mm in some areas. Medial wall fractures are second only to floor fractures in frequency in orbital trauma. The medial wall separates the orbit from the ethmoid air cells, and fractures in this wall allow air from the sinuses to enter the orbit (orbital emphysema) and may disrupt the medial canthal tendon attachment, causing traumatic telecanthus — widening of the intercanthal distance. Epistaxis (nosebleed) following an orbital medial wall fracture results from blood tracking through the ethmoid sinus into the nasal cavity.
The orbital roof is formed by the frontal bone and separates the orbit from the anterior cranial fossa. Roof fractures are less common than floor and medial wall fractures but carry greater severity because of their proximity to the brain, dura mater, and frontal lobes. Comminuted roof fractures may have intracranial extension, causing pneumocephalus (air in the cranial vault), CSF leak, or direct brain contusion. Traumatic optic neuropathy is most strongly associated with fractures of the optic canal (the tunnel through which the optic nerve exits the orbit), which can cause direct nerve injury or compression by hematoma or bony fragment.
The lateral wall — formed by the zygomatic bone anteriorly and the greater wing of the sphenoid posteriorly — is the strongest orbital wall and is rarely fractured in isolation. However, it is involved in zygomaticomaxillary complex (ZMC) fractures, the most common complex facial fracture in motor vehicle accidents, where the zygomatic bone separates from its four bony articulations: the frontal bone (frontotemporal suture), the maxillary bone (zygomaticomaxillary buttress), the sphenoid bone (sphenozygomatic suture), and the temporal bone (zygomatic arch). This "tripod fracture" produces malar eminence (cheekbone) depression, trismus (restricted mouth opening from impingement on the coronoid process of the mandible), lateral canthal displacement, and orbital floor involvement.
Blowout Fracture Mechanisms: Hydraulic and Buckling
Pure blowout fractures — fractures of the floor or medial wall without disruption of the orbital rim — are caused by two distinct biomechanical mechanisms. The hydraulic mechanism occurs when an object larger than the orbital aperture (such as an inflating airbag or a steering wheel component) strikes the globe directly, generating a sudden pressure wave transmitted through the incompressible vitreous humor and intraocular fluid to the orbital walls — preferentially fracturing the thinnest walls (floor and medial wall) inward and downward into the underlying sinuses. The buckling mechanism occurs when a direct blow to the orbital rim transmits bending stress waves along the orbital walls, causing buckling and fracture of the weakest portions (floor and medial wall) while the rim remains intact. In car accidents, airbag deployment generates both mechanisms simultaneously: the airbag contacts the periorbital rim (buckling) while the inflating bag also contacts and compresses the globe directly (hydraulic). This dual mechanism explains why airbag-related blowout fractures tend to be larger and more complex than blowout fractures from lower-energy mechanisms.
Associated Injuries: Diplopia, Enophthalmos, Globe Injury, and Optic Neuropathy
Diplopia (double vision) is the most common functional complication of orbital floor fractures, occurring when the inferior rectus muscle, inferior oblique muscle, or the periorbital fat and connective tissue surrounding these muscles becomes entrapped in the fracture defect or tethered to scar tissue at the fracture site. The inferior rectus controls downward gaze; the inferior oblique controls upward and outward gaze. Entrapment restricts the movement of these muscles, causing gaze-dependent diplopia — double vision when looking down (inferior rectus entrapment) or upward and outward (inferior oblique involvement). The white-eyed blowout fracture in children is a distinct emergency presentation: the orbital floor fractures like a trap door, entraps the inferior rectus with minimal external signs (no ecchymosis — hence "white-eyed"), and the oculocardiac reflex produces bradycardia, nausea, and syncope from vagal activation by the entrapped muscle. Without urgent surgical release within 24 hours, the muscle suffers ischemic necrosis and permanent fibrosis.
Enophthalmos — backward displacement of the globe from loss of orbital floor structural support — is a delayed complication of orbital floor fractures, typically developing over weeks to months as the herniated orbital fat undergoes atrophy. Clinically, enophthalmos greater than 2mm produces a sunken appearance of the affected eye, asymmetry of the upper eyelid sulcus, and impaired depth perception and stereoacuity from disrupted binocular alignment. Significant enophthalmos satisfies the significant disfigurement category of New York Insurance Law §5102(d) independently of the fracture per se category. Hertel exophthalmometry — measurement of globe position relative to the lateral orbital rim — is the standard clinical measurement tool, with enophthalmos defined as asymmetry greater than 2mm between the injured and uninjured eye.
Globe injuries occur simultaneously with orbital fractures in a significant proportion of car accident cases. Hyphema — bleeding into the anterior chamber of the eye — appears as a visible red layering of blood in the inferior anterior chamber and may cause elevated intraocular pressure requiring medical or surgical management. Commotio retinae is traumatic edema of the outer retinal layers that appears as a whitish-gray discoloration of the retina on fundoscopy, typically at the macula or periphery, and can cause permanent photoreceptor damage and visual acuity loss. Retinal detachment — separation of the neurosensory retina from the retinal pigment epithelium — may occur at the time of trauma or develop days to weeks later as a delayed complication; it presents with photopsia (light flashes), floaters, and a visual field curtain, and requires emergency retinal surgery. Traumatic optic neuropathy — injury to the optic nerve from direct concussion, compressive hematoma, or optic canal fracture — can cause immediate or delayed vision loss ranging from mild contrast sensitivity and color vision deficit to complete blindness in the affected eye.
Diagnosis, Imaging, and Surgical Treatment of Orbital Fractures
CT Orbit: Gold Standard for Orbital Fracture Diagnosis
CT of the orbits with dedicated axial and coronal reconstructions at 1mm slice thickness is the gold standard imaging study for orbital fracture diagnosis and surgical planning. Standard facial CT (at 2.5 to 3mm slice intervals) may miss small blowout fractures, medial wall fractures, and subtle floor defects that would be visible on dedicated orbital CT. The radiologist should specifically report: (1) which orbital walls are fractured; (2) the dimensions of any floor or medial wall defect in axial and coronal planes; (3) whether extraocular muscle tissue is visible within the defect (entrapment vs. herniation of fat alone); (4) the degree of herniation of periorbital fat into the maxillary or ethmoid sinus; (5) any air in the orbit (orbital emphysema indicating medial wall or floor fracture communicating with a sinus); (6) any optic canal involvement; and (7) any associated facial or intracranial injuries. MRI of the orbit provides superior soft tissue detail for evaluating extraocular muscle edema and fibrosis, optic nerve integrity, and orbital fat changes, and may be obtained as a supplement to CT when soft tissue discrimination is needed for surgical planning or when optic nerve injury is suspected. Ophthalmologic examination should include measurement of intraocular pressure, best-corrected visual acuity, pupil assessment for afferent pupillary defect, slit-lamp biomicroscopy of the anterior segment, and dilated funduscopic examination.
Surgical Repair: Transconjunctival Approach and Implant Selection
Surgical repair of orbital blowout fractures is performed through a transconjunctival incision — made through the inner surface of the lower eyelid, leaving no visible external scar — or a subciliary incision just below the lower lash line. The transconjunctival approach is preferred by most oculoplastic surgeons for isolated floor and medial wall fractures because it avoids ectropion risk and provides excellent orbital floor access. Through this incision, the periorbita is elevated from the orbital floor, herniated tissue is reduced from the sinus back into the orbit, and the bony defect is bridged with an implant. Implant choices include: titanium mesh — porous, biocompatible, rigid, provides permanent structural support, widely used for large floor defects and complex fractures; porous polyethylene (Medpor) — allows soft tissue ingrowth, highly biocompatible, available in preformed floor shapes, lower migration risk than older non-porous implants; and resorbable plates (polylactic acid, polyglycolic acid co-polymers) — used for small defects and in pediatric patients. ZMC fractures are repaired through open reduction and four-point rigid fixation: plates and screws are placed at the frontotemporal suture, the zygomaticomaxillary buttress, the infraorbital rim, and sometimes the zygomatic arch to restore the three-dimensional position of the malar eminence. Proper ZMC reduction restores facial projection, orbital volume, and rim alignment.
Complications: Persistent Diplopia, Permanent Enophthalmos, Implant Migration, and Ectropion
Even with technically successful surgical repair, orbital fractures carry a substantial complication burden. Persistent diplopia after surgical repair occurs in 15 to 40% of patients and, when present beyond 6 months, is generally considered permanent. Treatment options include prism glasses (which shift the visual image to compensate for ocular misalignment), botulinum toxin injection into the overacting antagonist muscle (temporary), or strabismus surgery — recession of the inferior rectus, resection of the superior rectus, or adjustment of the inferior oblique, performed by a strabismus specialist. Strabismus surgery generates substantial additional medical expenses and introduces additional risks including overcorrection requiring re-operation. Permanent enophthalmos despite floor repair may result from inadequate orbital volume restoration, late fat atrophy, or implant malposition, and may require secondary orbital volume augmentation with additional implant material. Implant migration — displacement of the floor implant inferiorly through the fracture gap — can occur weeks to years postoperatively and may require revision surgery. Ectropion — outward turning of the lower eyelid margin — is a complication of subciliary or infraciliary incision approaches, resulting from cicatricial contraction of the anterior lamella, and may require entropion repair with skin grafting or midface lifting.
New York Law: §5102(d) Serious Injury and Government Vehicle Claims
New York Insurance Law §5102(d) requires a plaintiff injured in a motor vehicle accident to establish a "serious injury" before bringing a claim for non-economic damages — pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, and consortium. Orbital fractures from car accidents satisfy the "fracture" category of §5102(d) as a matter of law: each confirmed fracture of any orbital wall — floor, medial wall, lateral wall, or roof — causally related to the accident is an independent per se serious injury. The fracture category does not require proof of permanence, functional restriction, or inability to perform daily activities — the confirmed fracture on CT imaging is itself the qualifying serious injury. This per se status is important because insurance carriers routinely attempt to minimize orbital fractures as "facial contusions" until CT imaging confirming fractures is produced.
Beyond the per se fracture category, orbital fracture cases with complications satisfy multiple additional §5102(d) categories. Permanent consequential limitation of use of a body organ or member is satisfied when persistent diplopia restricts extraocular motility in the primary field of gaze, when permanent enophthalmos alters globe position and impairs binocular vision, or when traumatic optic neuropathy produces measurable permanent vision loss. Significant disfigurement is satisfied when enophthalmos greater than 2mm produces a visible asymmetry of the eye socket, when surgical scarring at the orbital rim is visible, or when ZMC fracture reduction leaves residual malar depression despite surgery. Significant limitation of use of a body function or system is satisfied when persistent diplopia, reduced visual acuity, or restricted extraocular motility significantly limits the plaintiff's ability to drive, read, perform occupational tasks requiring visual precision, or engage in recreational activities requiring depth perception. Vision loss itself is an independent serious injury category under §5102(d). When all of these complications coexist — fracture, permanent diplopia, enophthalmos, and vision loss — the cumulative serious injury threshold is met under multiple independent grounds.
If the vehicle that caused the accident was a government-owned vehicle — a municipal bus, MTA bus, school bus, sanitation truck, highway department vehicle, or police car — you must file a Notice of Claim under General Municipal Law §50-e within 90 days of the accident. Missing this 90-day deadline bars your claim against the government entity. Your attorney must immediately identify all potentially liable government entities from the accident report. Visit our Long Island car accident lawyer page for more information about how New York no-fault insurance coordinates with an orbital fracture personal injury claim and the general process following a car accident on Long Island.
Representative Orbital Fracture Results
Past results do not guarantee future outcomes. Each case is evaluated on its own facts.
$620K
Orbital Blowout Fracture + Diplopia + Strabismus Surgery
Airbag deployment in a frontal collision on the Long Island Expressway caused a pure blowout fracture of the orbital floor with entrapment of the inferior rectus muscle confirmed on CT orbit coronal cuts; plaintiff, a 41-year-old airline pilot, developed immediate diplopia in downgaze and adduction; surgical repair via transconjunctival incision with titanium mesh implant performed within 12 days of injury; at 18 months, persistent binocular diplopia within 20 degrees of primary gaze required strabismus surgery with inferior rectus recession; ophthalmology expert documented permanent binocular diplopia inconsistent with commercial pilot certification requirements; vocational expert documented total loss of piloting career capacity.
$490K
ZMC Tripod Fracture + Enophthalmos + Infraorbital Nerve Injury
Steering wheel impact in a high-speed rear-end collision caused a zygomaticomaxillary complex (ZMC) tripod fracture involving the malar eminence, zygomatic arch, orbital rim, and orbital floor, confirmed on CT with 3D reconstruction; plaintiff underwent open reduction and internal fixation of the ZMC with four-point plate fixation; at 14 months, oculoplastic surgeon documented 3.5mm enophthalmos (globe sunken appearance) on Hertel exophthalmometry satisfying the significant disfigurement category; infraorbital nerve injury produced permanent cheek and upper lip numbness (V2 territory hypoesthesia) documented on sensory testing; additional titanium mesh implant placed for enophthalmos correction at 16 months.
$375K
Orbital Floor Fracture + Globe Injury + Commotio Retinae
Side-view mirror intrusion in a sideswipe collision on Sunrise Highway caused an impure blowout fracture of the left orbital floor with rim involvement and traumatic globe injury; emergency ophthalmology examination documented hyphema (blood in anterior chamber), commotio retinae (retinal contusion visible on fundoscopy), and reduced visual acuity of 20/80; surgical floor repair with Medpor implant performed at 10 days; at 20 months, retinal specialist documented permanent best-corrected visual acuity of 20/40 in the injured eye from macular commotio changes; vision loss satisfied both the permanent consequential limitation category and the vision loss category of §5102(d).
$295K
Medial Wall Orbital Fracture + Traumatic Epiphora + Epistaxis
Dashboard impact in a low-speed intersection collision caused a medial wall orbital fracture through the lamina papyracea of the ethmoid with air-fluid level in the ethmoid sinus on CT; plaintiff developed epistaxis at the scene and subsequent traumatic epiphora (excessive tearing from lacrimal drainage obstruction); orbital and ENT evaluation confirmed disruption of the nasolacrimal duct system; dacryocystorhinostomy (DCR) surgery performed at 3 months; at 12 months, ophthalmologist documented persistent symptomatic epiphora requiring Jones tube implantation as a permanent drainage solution; fracture per se satisfied each §5102(d) category.
$210K
Orbital Roof Fracture + Traumatic Optic Neuropathy Risk
Ejection from a convertible on the Southern State Parkway caused an orbital roof fracture with intracranial extension confirmed on CT and MRI; neurosurgery consult performed emergently given proximity to the anterior cranial fossa; serial visual evoked potentials documented subclinical optic nerve conduction delay consistent with traumatic optic neuropathy; at 12 months, neuro-ophthalmologist documented persistent contrast sensitivity deficit and visual field constriction in the superior temporal quadrant; multiple §5102(d) categories satisfied including fracture per se, permanent consequential limitation of visual function, and significant limitation of daily activities.
$145K
Pure Blowout Fracture + Transient Diplopia + Full Recovery
Airbag deployment in a frontal collision caused a pure blowout fracture of the orbital floor with a 40% floor defect on coronal CT; diplopia in downgaze documented at presentation; surgical repair with titanium mesh performed within 14 days; at 12 months, diplopia had resolved and Hertel exophthalmometry showed 1mm asymmetry within normal limits; fracture per se satisfied §5102(d) as a matter of law despite absence of permanent functional limitation; plaintiff, a 35-year-old teacher, documented 8 weeks of missed work and pain and suffering during the surgical and recovery period.
Factors That Increase Orbital Fracture Claim Value
Not all orbital fracture claims carry the same value. Several medical, occupational, and legal factors significantly increase the recovery in an orbital fracture case in New York:
Permanent Diplopia Requiring Strabismus Surgery
Persistent binocular diplopia within 30 degrees of primary gaze at 12 months post-repair, requiring strabismus surgery with inferior rectus recession or inferior oblique weakening, represents one of the highest-value orbital fracture outcomes. Strabismus surgery generates additional recoverable medical expenses, introduces the risk of overcorrection, and provides powerful evidence of permanent functional visual disability. For plaintiffs in occupations requiring binocular vision and precise depth perception — commercial pilots, surgeons, professional drivers, athletes, and construction workers operating at heights — permanent diplopia may prevent return to the occupation entirely, generating substantial vocational loss damages in addition to non-economic damages.
Traumatic Optic Neuropathy with Vision Loss
Traumatic optic neuropathy producing permanent visual acuity reduction, visual field defect, color vision loss, or contrast sensitivity impairment is the most severe visual complication of orbital fractures. Vision loss independently satisfies the vision loss category of §5102(d) and generates lifetime damages from the loss of visual function. For plaintiffs in any occupation requiring visual precision, optic nerve injury producing even modest permanent acuity reduction (e.g., 20/40 vs. 20/20) can generate substantial economic damages from career limitation and vocational retraining costs. Complete or near-complete vision loss in the affected eye produces the highest damage awards in orbital fracture litigation, particularly for younger plaintiffs facing decades of life with monocular vision.
Significant Enophthalmos Requiring Implant Surgery
Enophthalmos exceeding 2mm, producing a visible asymmetry of the affected eye socket, satisfies the significant disfigurement category of §5102(d) independently of the fracture per se category. The visible cosmetic deformity from an enophthalmic eye — appearing sunken compared to the fellow eye with a deepened upper lid sulcus — is readily apparent to juries and requires no medical expert to explain. Cases requiring secondary orbital volume augmentation with additional titanium mesh, hydroxyapatite granules, or alloplastic implants to correct late enophthalmos generate additional surgical expenses and reinforce the permanence narrative at trial.
ZMC Fracture with Malar Depression and Four-Point Fixation
Zygomaticomaxillary complex fractures requiring open reduction and internal fixation at four bony buttress points are complex craniofacial procedures generating $25,000 to $60,000 in surgical expenses, carrying risks of facial numbness from infraorbital nerve injury, malar asymmetry from malreduction, and trismus from coronoid process impingement. The malar eminence (cheekbone prominence) is a primary determinant of facial appearance; depression of the malar eminence from an inadequately reduced or malunited ZMC fracture produces permanent facial asymmetry that satisfies the significant disfigurement category and generates substantial non-economic damages for cosmetic-conscious plaintiffs.
Profession Requiring Binocular Vision (Pilot, Surgeon, Athlete, Driver)
The economic impact of orbital fracture complications is dramatically amplified for plaintiffs in professions where binocular vision, precise depth perception, and monocular visual acuity are occupational requirements. Commercial pilots certified under FAA standards require binocular diplopia-free vision and corrected visual acuity of 20/20 in each eye; permanent diplopia or monocular vision loss disqualifies a commercial pilot permanently and generates vocational damages reflecting the full present value of a lifetime piloting career. Surgeons, interventional cardiologists, and other proceduralists depending on binocular surgical vision may be unable to perform their specialty procedures. Professional drivers holding commercial driver's licenses (CDL) face revocation for monocular vision. In high-wage professions, vocational expert analysis of career loss may generate economic damages of $1,000,000 to $3,000,000, dominating the total damages calculation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Answers to common questions about orbital fracture car accident claims in New York.
What is an orbital fracture?
An orbital fracture is a break in one or more of the four bony walls that form the eye socket — the orbit. The orbit is a roughly pyramidal bony cavity housing the eyeball, extraocular muscles, optic nerve, orbital fat, and lacrimal system. Its four walls are: the roof (floor of the anterior cranial fossa, formed primarily by the frontal bone), the floor (roof of the maxillary sinus, formed by the maxillary, palatine, and zygomatic bones), the medial wall (paper-thin lamina papyracea of the ethmoid bone, the most fragile wall), and the lateral wall (formed by the zygomatic bone and greater wing of the sphenoid). The orbital floor is the most frequently fractured wall in car accidents because it is thin — less than 1mm in the posterior portion above the maxillary sinus — and because it is directly exposed to the hydraulic pressure wave generated when an object strikes the globe or periorbital region. Orbital fractures range from isolated pure blowout fractures (floor or medial wall only, without rim fracture) to complex patterns including the zygomaticomaxillary complex (ZMC) tripod fracture, nasoorbitoethmoid (NOE) fracture, and orbital roof fracture with intracranial extension. Each type carries distinct risks to vision, eye movement, facial appearance, and associated structures, and each satisfies New York Insurance Law §5102(d) as a fracture per se serious injury.
Can a car accident cause an orbital blowout fracture?
Yes. Car accidents are a leading cause of orbital fractures, and the periorbital region is highly vulnerable to multiple distinct mechanisms of injury in motor vehicle collisions. Airbag deployment is a significant cause of orbital blowout fractures: the rapidly inflating airbag strikes the face with substantial force, and the periorbital rim receives direct impact force that can generate the hydraulic pressure or buckling mechanism responsible for pure blowout fractures of the orbital floor or medial wall. Studies have documented that airbag-related orbital fractures account for a meaningful proportion of orbital fractures seen in motor vehicle accident patients. Steering wheel impact in frontal collisions — particularly in unbelted occupants or in collisions where the airbag failed to deploy — delivers direct force to the mid-face including the orbital rim and zygomaticomaxillary complex, producing ZMC or impure blowout fractures. Side-view mirror intrusion in sideswipe collisions directs energy precisely to the lateral orbital rim. Dashboard impact in low-speed collisions can fracture the orbital floor through the periorbital region. Ejection from a convertible or motorcycle accident with facial contact with the road surface can cause severe complex orbital fractures with intracranial extension. Flying objects — in convertible accidents or through broken windshields — can strike the periorbital region directly. In all of these mechanisms, orbital fractures may be accompanied by globe injury (hyphema, lens dislocation, retinal detachment), traumatic optic neuropathy from optic canal fracture, and associated facial fractures, each of which independently increases the value of the legal claim.
Does an orbital fracture require surgery?
Not all orbital fractures require surgical repair, but surgical indications are clearly established in the ophthalmic and oculoplastic surgery literature, and failing to meet surgical indications promptly can result in permanent complications. The main indications for orbital fracture surgical repair are: (1) significant enophthalmos exceeding 2mm — globe sinking backward from loss of orbital floor support — which causes cosmetic deformity and may impair depth perception; (2) persistent diplopia (double vision) within 30 degrees of primary gaze, particularly when CT confirms muscle or soft tissue entrapment in the fracture defect; (3) large floor defect exceeding 50% of the orbital floor area — large defects predictably cause late enophthalmos even if not present initially, because the orbital fat and periorbita herniate into the maxillary sinus over time; (4) white-eyed blowout fracture in children — a pediatric emergency where a trap-door fracture entraps and strangles the inferior rectus muscle with minimal external findings, producing the oculocardiac reflex (bradycardia, nausea, syncope) and requiring urgent surgical release to prevent permanent muscle ischemia and motility restriction; and (5) inferior rectus muscle entrapment confirmed on CT with positive forced duction testing. Surgical approaches include transconjunctival incision (through the inside of the lower eyelid — leaves no visible scar) or subciliary incision (just below the lash line). The fractured floor is repaired with a titanium mesh implant, a porous polyethylene (Medpor) implant, or resorbable materials to restore orbital volume and support the globe. ZMC fractures require open reduction and internal fixation with plate and screw systems at multiple buttress points. The timing of surgery matters: repair within 2 weeks generally produces better outcomes for diplopia and enophthalmos than delayed repair.
What is the settlement value of an orbital fracture in New York?
The settlement value of an orbital fracture case in New York depends on the fracture type, the associated injuries, whether surgery was required, the extent of permanent complications, and the plaintiff's occupation and age. Simple orbital floor fractures without surgery and with full recovery typically settle in the range of $80,000 to $175,000, reflecting the pain and suffering during the 8 to 12-week recovery period, the fracture per se serious injury threshold, and any residual periorbital sensitivity. Orbital fractures requiring surgical repair with titanium mesh or Medpor implant typically settle in the range of $175,000 to $375,000, depending on the extent of the repair, associated globe injury, and permanence of any diplopia or enophthalmos. High-value orbital fracture cases — those settling above $400,000 or proceeding to verdict — typically involve one or more of the following: permanent diplopia requiring prism glasses or strabismus surgery with inferior rectus recession; significant enophthalmos (greater than 2mm) causing cosmetic disfigurement and depth perception impairment; traumatic optic neuropathy with permanent vision loss; globe injury with permanent best-corrected visual acuity loss; orbital implant complications requiring revision surgery; infraorbital nerve injury with permanent cheek numbness affecting quality of life; or an occupation requiring binocular vision or visual acuity (commercial pilot, surgeon, professional athlete, driver) where the injury prevents return to work. Economic damages from vision loss or profession-ending eye injuries can add $500,000 to $2,000,000 to the damages calculation in high-wage cases.
Can orbital fractures cause permanent vision problems?
Yes. Orbital fractures carry a range of vision-threatening complications that can produce permanent visual impairment. Diplopia — double vision from disruption of extraocular muscle function — is the most common vision-related complication of orbital floor fractures, occurring when the inferior rectus or inferior oblique muscle becomes entrapped in or adherent to the orbital floor fracture site, restricting upward or lateral gaze and creating misalignment of the visual axes. While some diplopia resolves with conservative management or early surgical repair, persistent diplopia within 30 degrees of primary gaze at 6 to 12 months post-injury is considered permanent and requires prism glasses or strabismus surgery (extraocular muscle recession or resection) for correction — and may never fully resolve. Enophthalmos — backward displacement of the globe from loss of orbital floor support — impairs depth perception and stereoacuity, and significant enophthalmos (greater than 2mm) causes cosmetic deformity that satisfies the significant disfigurement category of §5102(d). Traumatic optic neuropathy — injury to the optic nerve from direct trauma, compression by hematoma, or optic canal fracture — can cause permanent vision loss ranging from mild contrast sensitivity reduction to complete blindness in the affected eye; it is the most severe visual complication of orbital fractures. Globe injuries occurring simultaneously with orbital fractures — hyphema (blood in the anterior chamber), lens dislocation, commotio retinae (retinal contusion), retinal dialysis, or traumatic vitreous hemorrhage — can independently cause permanent best-corrected visual acuity loss. All of these permanent complications satisfy multiple categories of New York Insurance Law §5102(d), including the vision loss category, the permanent consequential limitation category, and the significant disfigurement category.
How long does it take to recover from an orbital fracture?
Recovery from an orbital fracture depends on the fracture type, whether surgery was required, and the nature of any associated complications. For non-surgical orbital floor fractures with minimal or no diplopia, most patients see significant improvement in periorbital swelling and ecchymosis within 2 to 3 weeks, and any diplopia from periorbital edema (rather than true muscle entrapment) typically resolves within 4 to 8 weeks. CT imaging follow-up at 6 weeks typically confirms stable fracture position. Most patients with isolated blowout fractures managed conservatively return to baseline function within 8 to 12 weeks. For patients undergoing surgical repair, the postoperative recovery period involves 6 to 8 weeks of activity restriction — no nose-blowing (which increases retrobulbar pressure), no contact sports, and no strenuous exertion. Postoperative diplopia may improve progressively over 3 to 6 months as periorbital edema resolves and extraocular muscle function recovers. However, if diplopia persists beyond 6 months despite surgical repair, it is generally considered to have a permanent component, and strabismus surgery should be considered. Enophthalmos, once established, does not resolve without surgical intervention. Infraorbital nerve hypoesthesia (cheek numbness from injury to the V2 branch of the trigeminal nerve) typically shows partial improvement over 6 to 18 months in patients with neurapraxia, but permanent anesthesia or paresthesia is common when the nerve is directly compressed or lacerated by the fracture. From a legal standpoint, maximum medical improvement (MMI) for orbital fractures should not be declared before 12 to 18 months post-injury, as complications including late enophthalmos, implant migration, ectropion (outward turning of the lower eyelid), and persistent diplopia may manifest or declare their permanence during this period.
Free Settlement Calculator
Estimate what your personal injury case may be worth using real New York settlement data and proven calculation methods.
Calculate Your EstimateEducational tool only. Not legal advice.
Reviewed & Verified By
Jason Tenenbaum, Esq.
Jason Tenenbaum is a personal injury attorney serving Long Island, Nassau & Suffolk Counties, and New York City. Admitted to practice in NY, NJ, FL, TX, GA, MI, and Federal courts, Jason is one of the few attorneys who writes his own appeals and tries his own cases. Since 2002, he has authored over 2,353 articles on no-fault insurance law, personal injury, and employment law — a resource other attorneys rely on to stay current on New York appellate decisions.
Suffered an Orbital Fracture in a Long Island Car Accident?
Orbital fractures are serious injuries under New York law. Do not let the insurance company minimize your eye socket injury claim. Call us today for a free consultation — no fee unless we win.