Skip to main content
★★★★★ 4.9 Rating • 200+ Reviews

Long Island Bedsore &
Pressure Ulcer Lawyer

Bedsores are almost always preventable. When a nursing home allows pressure ulcers to develop, it’s a clear sign of neglect. We hold facilities accountable and fight for full compensation. No fee unless we win.

$100M+

Recovered

24+

Years Experience

$0

Upfront Cost

24/7

Available

Nursing Home Pressure Injury Attorney

Bedsore & Pressure Ulcer Lawyer on Long Island

Bedsores — clinically known as pressure ulcers or decubitus ulcers — are among the most telling indicators of nursing home neglect. These wounds develop when sustained pressure on the skin restricts blood flow, causing tissue to break down and die. They are painful, disfiguring, and in advanced stages, potentially fatal. What makes bedsores especially significant in a legal context is that they are almost entirely preventable with basic nursing care — regular repositioning, proper nutrition, skin inspections, and appropriate bedding surfaces.

When a nursing home resident develops pressure ulcers, it almost always means the facility failed to provide the minimum standard of care required by both federal regulations and New York State law. At the Law Office of Jason Tenenbaum, we represent families across Nassau County and Suffolk County who have watched their loved ones suffer from avoidable pressure injuries. We investigate the facility’s care records, consult with wound care experts, and pursue claims under New York’s Public Health Law §2801-d and other legal theories to recover full compensation.

If your loved one has developed bedsores in a Long Island nursing home, call (516) 750-0595 for a free, confidential consultation. Time-sensitive evidence — turning logs, staffing records, wound care documentation — can be altered or destroyed if you wait.

What Are Bedsores (Pressure Ulcers)?

Bedsores are localized injuries to the skin and underlying tissue that result from prolonged pressure on the body. When a person remains in the same position for an extended period — whether lying in bed or sitting in a wheelchair — the sustained pressure compresses blood vessels, cutting off oxygen and nutrient delivery to the affected tissue. Without adequate blood flow, the skin and underlying structures begin to deteriorate and die.

The process is not subtle or sudden. Pressure ulcers develop over hours and days of immobility. A patient who is repositioned every two hours — the universally accepted standard of care — will almost never develop a bedsore. The wounds primarily affect patients who cannot reposition themselves: those with paralysis, severe arthritis, dementia, post-surgical immobility, or general frailty associated with advanced age. These are precisely the patients who depend entirely on nursing home staff to move them, check their skin, and respond to the earliest signs of tissue damage.

The most common locations for pressure ulcers include the sacrum (tailbone area), heels, hips, shoulder blades, elbows, and the back of the head. In wheelchair-bound patients, the ischial tuberosities (sit bones) and coccyx are especially vulnerable. The risk factors are well-documented in medical literature: immobility, malnutrition, dehydration, incontinence, diabetes, vascular disease, and advanced age. Every nursing home is required to assess these risk factors upon admission and develop a prevention care plan accordingly.

If your family member is in a Long Island nursing home and you have noticed skin changes, redness that does not fade, or open wounds, call (516) 750-0595 immediately. Early detection and legal intervention can prevent a bad situation from becoming catastrophic.

Bedsore Staging System

The National Pressure Injury Advisory Panel (NPIAP) classifies pressure ulcers into four stages, plus two additional categories. Understanding the staging system is essential because the stage of the wound directly correlates with the severity of neglect and the potential value of a legal claim.

Stage I — Non-Blanchable Erythema

The skin is intact but shows a localized area of non-blanchable redness — meaning the reddened area does not turn white when you press on it with a finger. The area may be painful, firm, soft, or warmer than surrounding skin. In patients with darker skin tones, Stage I ulcers may present as persistent discoloration rather than redness. Stage I represents the earliest detectable sign of tissue damage. At this point, the wound is fully reversible with proper pressure relief. When a nursing home fails to identify and respond to Stage I indicators, it demonstrates a breakdown in basic skin assessment protocols.

Stage II — Partial-Thickness Skin Loss

The dermis is exposed, creating a shallow open wound with a red or pink wound bed. It may also present as an intact or ruptured fluid-filled blister. Stage II ulcers are painful and indicate that the tissue damage has progressed beyond the surface layer. At this stage, the wound requires active wound care management — moisture management, protective dressings, and aggressive repositioning. A Stage II bedsore in a nursing home resident should trigger an immediate reassessment of the care plan, notification of the attending physician, and documentation of all interventions.

Stage III — Full-Thickness Skin Loss

The wound extends through the full thickness of the skin into the subcutaneous fat layer. Bone, tendon, and muscle are not yet visible, but the wound may include undermining and tunneling — extensions of the wound beneath intact skin that indicate the damage is more extensive than what is visible on the surface. Stage III pressure ulcers represent a serious medical condition requiring aggressive wound care including wound vac (negative pressure wound therapy), specialized dressings, and potentially surgical debridement. The development of a Stage III bedsore in a nursing home is powerful evidence of sustained, systemic neglect — these wounds do not develop overnight.

Stage IV — Full-Thickness Tissue Loss

The most severe stage. The wound extends through the skin and subcutaneous tissue, exposing bone, tendon, or muscle. Stage IV ulcers are deep, often foul-smelling, and carry a high risk of life-threatening infection including osteomyelitis (bone infection) and sepsis. Treatment frequently requires surgical intervention — debridement of necrotic tissue, possible skin grafts, and prolonged hospitalization. Stage IV bedsores can take months or years to heal, and many never fully close in elderly patients. The development of a Stage IV pressure ulcer in a nursing home setting is considered prima facie evidence of grossly inadequate care.

Unstageable Pressure Ulcers

When the wound bed is covered by slough (yellow, tan, gray, or brown dead tissue) or eschar (thick, black, leathery dead tissue), the true depth and stage cannot be determined until the necrotic tissue is removed. Unstageable wounds are presumed to be at least Stage III and often reveal Stage IV damage once debrided. The presence of eschar-covered wounds is especially concerning because it suggests the injury has been present and untreated for a significant period.

Deep Tissue Pressure Injury (DTPI)

Intact or non-intact skin with a persistent, non-blanchable deep red, maroon, or purple discoloration, or separation of the epidermis revealing a dark wound bed. DTPI indicates damage to underlying soft tissue from pressure and/or shear forces. These injuries can evolve rapidly, and the full extent of tissue damage may not be apparent for days after the initial observation. Deep tissue injuries can progress to Stage III or Stage IV wounds even with appropriate treatment once discovered, making early identification critical.

Critical Legal Point

Stage III & IV Bedsores Are Prima Facie Evidence of Neglect

The development of an advanced bedsore in a nursing home setting is almost always preventable. CMS survey guidelines treat avoidable Stage III and IV pressure ulcers as deficiencies that trigger enforcement action. In civil lawsuits, the presence of advanced bedsores creates a strong presumption that the facility failed to meet the minimum standard of care — shifting the burden to the nursing home to explain how the wound developed despite purportedly adequate care.

Why Bedsores Are Almost Always Preventable

The medical and regulatory communities agree: with proper care, the vast majority of pressure ulcers are avoidable. The prevention protocols are not complex, experimental, or costly — they are basic nursing care measures that every skilled nursing facility is required to implement.

  • Repositioning every two hours — the cornerstone of bedsore prevention. Immobile patients must be turned or repositioned at regular intervals to relieve pressure on vulnerable areas. Nursing homes are required to document each repositioning in the patient’s turning log. When a facility cannot produce consistent turning records, it is strong evidence that repositioning was not performed.
  • Pressure-redistribution mattresses and surfaces — alternating-pressure air mattresses, low-air-loss mattresses, and specialized wheelchair cushions distribute the patient’s weight across a larger surface area, reducing the concentrated pressure that causes tissue breakdown. These devices are standard equipment in properly resourced nursing homes.
  • Nutrition and hydration — adequate protein intake and hydration are essential for skin integrity. Malnourished and dehydrated patients are at dramatically higher risk of developing pressure ulcers and healing existing wounds. Nursing homes must assess nutritional status regularly and provide dietary supplements when needed.
  • Daily skin inspections — certified nursing assistants and licensed nurses must conduct systematic skin assessments, especially on high-risk areas (sacrum, heels, hips, elbows). Early identification of Stage I indicators allows intervention before tissue damage becomes irreversible.
  • Wound care protocols — when early-stage pressure injuries are identified, the facility must implement immediate wound care interventions including moisture management, protective dressings, increased repositioning frequency, and physician notification.
  • Incontinence management — prolonged exposure to moisture from urine or feces accelerates skin breakdown. Proper incontinence care — timely changing, barrier creams, and skin cleansing protocols — is a critical component of bedsore prevention.

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) codifies these requirements under F-tag F686, which mandates that nursing homes must ensure residents receive care to prevent pressure ulcers from developing (unless clinically unavoidable) and to heal existing pressure ulcers. Violations of F686 are among the most commonly cited deficiencies in CMS nursing home surveys — and they are directly relevant evidence in civil lawsuits.

Has your loved one developed bedsores despite being in a staffed nursing facility? This is not an acceptable outcome. Call (516) 750-0595 to discuss your legal options.

Bedsores as Evidence of Nursing Home Neglect

The legal significance of bedsores in nursing home abuse cases cannot be overstated. Because pressure ulcers are overwhelmingly preventable with basic care, their presence — particularly at advanced stages — serves as powerful circumstantial evidence that the facility breached its duty of care to the resident.

From a regulatory standpoint, the New York Department of Health investigates bedsore complaints and cites facilities for deficiencies related to pressure ulcer prevention and treatment. CMS survey guidelines explicitly state that the development of a new pressure ulcer or the worsening of an existing one must be assessed to determine whether it was avoidable. An “avoidable” pressure ulcer is one that developed because the facility did not evaluate the resident’s risk, did not implement individualized interventions consistent with recognized standards of practice, or did not monitor and revise interventions as necessary.

In civil litigation, the resident’s medical records become the central evidence. Our attorneys and medical experts examine:

  • Braden Scale assessments — the standard risk-assessment tool used in nursing homes to evaluate a patient’s susceptibility to pressure ulcers. Failure to conduct timely Braden Scale assessments or to act on high-risk scores is evidence of negligence.
  • Turning and repositioning logs — gaps in documentation, implausible patterns (exact same times recorded every shift), or missing records suggest that repositioning was not performed as required.
  • Wound care records — documentation of wound assessments, dressing changes, physician orders for wound care, and referrals to wound care specialists.
  • Staffing records — understaffing is the root cause of most bedsore cases. We subpoena staffing schedules to determine whether the facility had enough personnel to provide the repositioning, skin checks, and wound care required by each resident’s care plan.
  • Nutritional records — dietary assessments, calorie counts, hydration logs, and dietitian consultations that demonstrate whether the facility addressed the resident’s nutritional needs.

When these records reveal gaps, inconsistencies, or outright fabrication, they form the evidentiary foundation for a powerful nursing home abuse claim.

Need help obtaining and analyzing your loved one’s nursing home records? Call (516) 750-0595 for a free case evaluation.

Who Is Liable for Bedsore Injuries?

Bedsore cases often involve multiple potentially liable parties. We investigate every link in the chain of care to identify all responsible entities and maximize the recovery for our clients:

  • The nursing home facility (corporate owner) — the entity that owns and operates the facility bears primary responsibility for ensuring adequate staffing, training, and adherence to care protocols. Corporate ownership structures in the nursing home industry are often deliberately complex — separating the real estate holding company, the operating company, and the management company to insulate assets from lawsuits. Our firm traces the full corporate chain to identify all entities with liability.
  • Nursing staff — individual nurses and certified nursing assistants who were assigned to care for the resident and failed to perform repositioning, skin assessments, or wound care as required by the care plan.
  • Wound care nurse or specialist — if the facility employed or contracted a wound care nurse, their failure to assess, treat, or escalate a developing or worsening pressure ulcer constitutes a separate basis for liability.
  • Medical director — the physician responsible for overseeing medical care at the facility may be liable for failure to establish wound care protocols, failure to respond to reports of developing pressure ulcers, or failure to order appropriate diagnostic imaging or specialist referrals.
  • Management company — many nursing homes are operated by management companies that control day-to-day operations, staffing budgets, and care policies. When cost-cutting decisions by the management company contribute to understaffing and inadequate care, they share liability.

Identifying all liable parties is critical because it expands the available insurance coverage and increases the total recovery. Call (516) 750-0595 to discuss who may be responsible for your loved one’s pressure injuries.

New York Legal Claims for Bedsore Injuries

Families pursuing legal action for bedsores caused by nursing home neglect in New York have several legal theories available, each with its own statute of limitations, burden of proof, and damages structure:

Public Health Law §2801-d

New York’s most powerful tool for holding nursing homes accountable. PHL §2801-d creates a private right of action for any nursing home resident who has been deprived of a right or benefit protected by federal or state law, regulation, or code. Since federal regulations (42 CFR §483.25) and CMS F-tag F686 require facilities to prevent avoidable pressure ulcers, the development of bedsores due to inadequate care constitutes a deprivation of rights under this statute. Damages include compensatory damages for all injuries, a 25% punitive surcharge on compensatory damages payable to the state, and reasonable attorneys’ fees. The statute of limitations is 3 years.

Common-Law Negligence

A straightforward negligence claim requires proving that the facility owed a duty of care to the resident, breached that duty by failing to prevent or treat bedsores, and that the breach caused the resident’s injuries and damages. The standard of care is established through medical expert testimony. The statute of limitations is 3 years under CPLR §214.

Medical Malpractice

When licensed medical professionals — physicians, nurse practitioners, registered nurses — fail to order appropriate wound care, fail to diagnose an infection in a pressure ulcer, or fail to escalate a worsening wound, the claim may sound in medical malpractice. Malpractice claims carry a shorter 2.5-year statute of limitations under CPLR §214-a and require a certificate of merit from a medical expert. Many bedsore cases involve overlapping negligence and malpractice theories, and we pursue all applicable claims to maximize recovery.

Wrongful Death

When a bedsore leads to sepsis, organ failure, or other fatal complications, the resident’s estate may bring a wrongful death action under EPTL §5-4.1. Wrongful death damages include pre-death conscious pain and suffering, funeral and burial costs, loss of financial support, and loss of parental guidance. The statute of limitations is 2 years from the date of death. These cases are particularly compelling because the causal chain — from neglect to bedsore to infection to death — is well-established in medical literature.

Statute of Limitations Warning

Filing Deadlines Are Strict and Unforgiving

Negligence and PHL §2801-d claims: 3 years. Medical malpractice: 2.5 years. Wrongful death: 2 years from date of death. Government-run facilities: 90-day Notice of Claim. Missing any deadline permanently bars the claim. Contact us at (516) 750-0595 before it’s too late.

Compensation Available in Bedsore Cases

Bedsore injuries — particularly advanced-stage wounds — result in substantial damages because of the severity of the medical treatment required, the prolonged suffering involved, and the disfigurement that often results. Recoverable compensation includes:

  • Medical treatment costs — wound vac (negative pressure wound therapy), surgical debridement, skin grafts, flap surgery, hospitalization, antibiotics for infection, and ongoing wound care that can continue for months or years. Advanced bedsores are among the most expensive wounds to treat.
  • Pain and suffering — bedsores are excruciatingly painful. Stage III and IV wounds cause deep, persistent pain that is difficult to manage even with medication. The pain of dressing changes, debridement procedures, and wound vac therapy adds additional suffering. Courts recognize the severe nature of this pain in damage awards.
  • Disfigurement — advanced bedsores leave permanent scarring. Even after healing, the affected areas are visibly disfigured. New York law allows separate compensation for disfigurement, which can be substantial depending on the location and extent of scarring.
  • PHL §2801-d surcharge — a 25% surcharge on compensatory damages, payable to the state, as an additional deterrent against nursing home neglect. While the surcharge goes to the state, it effectively increases the total judgment against the facility.
  • Wrongful death damages — if the resident died from bedsore-related complications (sepsis, osteomyelitis, organ failure), the estate may recover funeral costs, pre-death conscious pain and suffering, loss of companionship, and loss of financial support.
  • Punitive damages — in cases involving particularly egregious neglect, willful indifference, or deliberate understaffing, courts may award punitive damages beyond compensatory damages to punish the facility and deter similar conduct.

Use our settlement calculator for a preliminary estimate of your case value, then call (516) 750-0595 for a detailed evaluation based on the specific facts of your loved one’s situation.

Why Hire Jason Tenenbaum for Your Bedsore Case

Jason Tenenbaum has spent 24 years representing injured Long Islanders and holding negligent parties accountable. In nursing home abuse cases, that experience translates into a deep understanding of the medical, regulatory, and legal frameworks that govern bedsore claims.

We work with board-certified wound care specialists and geriatricians who can analyze your loved one’s medical records, assess whether the bedsore was avoidable, and provide authoritative testimony on the standard of care. We obtain DOH inspection records, staffing data, CMS star ratings, and complaint histories to demonstrate patterns of systemic neglect. We trace corporate ownership structures to ensure every liable entity is named in the lawsuit.

Jason handles every case personally from first consultation through trial or settlement. He writes his own briefs, takes his own depositions, and stands in front of the judge himself. Consultations are free, and you pay nothing unless we recover compensation for you.

Get Your Free Bedsore Case Evaluation

Contact our experienced Long Island personal injury attorneys for a free, confidential consultation about your loved one’s pressure ulcer injuries. We’ll review the medical records, assess the facility’s compliance history, and give you a realistic assessment of your claim.

Related practice areas: Nursing Home AbuseNursing Home NeglectNursing Home FallsMedication ErrorsSigns of AbusePersonal InjuryMedical MalpracticeBrain InjuryCatastrophic InjuryWrongful DeathPain & SufferingSettlement Calculator

Simple Process

Getting Started Takes 5 Minutes

1

Call or Click

Reach us 24/7 at (516) 750-0595 or fill out our online form. We respond within minutes.

2

Free Medical Record Review

We obtain your loved one’s care records, wound care documentation, staffing data, and DOH inspection reports. We work with medical experts to determine whether the bedsore was avoidable.

3

We Fight. They Pay.

We handle the investigation, expert retention, depositions, and litigation. You focus on your family. We don’t get paid until you do.

Why Tenenbaum Law

Built to Win Bedsore & Pressure Ulcer Cases

Bedsore cases require an attorney who understands wound care medicine, nursing home staffing regulations, and the complex corporate structures that facilities use to shield assets. Jason Tenenbaum has spent 24 years fighting for injured Long Islanders and holding negligent nursing homes accountable.

Wound Care Expert Network

We work with board-certified wound care specialists who can analyze medical records, assess staging accuracy, and testify on whether the facility followed proper prevention and treatment protocols.

PHL §2801-d Expertise

Deep knowledge of New York’s private right of action statute and how to leverage the 25% punitive surcharge to increase the total recovery for our clients.

Regulatory Investigation

We obtain DOH inspection reports, F-tag citations, staffing records, and CMS data to demonstrate patterns of systemic neglect that go beyond a single resident’s case.

Contingency Fee — Zero Upfront Cost

We advance all investigation, expert, and litigation costs. You pay nothing unless we recover compensation for your family.

Nursing homes have corporate lawyers and insurance carriers whose job is to deny your claim. You need an attorney who understands wound care medicine, knows how to read turning logs and staffing records, and is willing to take the case to trial if the facility refuses a fair settlement.

24+

Years Experience

$0

Unless We Win

Common Questions

Bedsore & Pressure Ulcer FAQ

Are bedsores a sign of nursing home neglect?
In most cases, yes. Bedsores — also called pressure ulcers or decubitus ulcers — are almost always preventable with proper care. The standard of care in nursing homes requires repositioning immobile residents every two hours, using pressure-redistribution mattresses, maintaining adequate nutrition and hydration, conducting regular skin assessments, and implementing individualized care plans for at-risk residents. When a nursing home resident develops a Stage III or Stage IV pressure ulcer, it is strong evidence that the facility failed to follow these basic protocols. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) treats the development of avoidable pressure ulcers as a deficiency under F-tag F686, and the New York Department of Health investigates and cites facilities for such failures. If your loved one has developed bedsores in a nursing home, you should consult an attorney immediately — the presence of advanced pressure injuries is one of the clearest indicators of neglect.
What are the stages of bedsores and when should I contact a lawyer?
Bedsores are classified into four stages plus two additional categories. Stage I presents as non-blanchable redness on intact skin — the area does not turn white when pressed. Stage II involves partial-thickness skin loss with a shallow open wound or fluid-filled blister. Stage III is full-thickness skin loss where subcutaneous fat may be visible, but bone, tendon, and muscle are not exposed. Stage IV is full-thickness tissue loss with exposed bone, tendon, or muscle — these wounds are deep, often infected, and can be life-threatening. Unstageable pressure ulcers are covered by dead tissue (slough or eschar) that prevents accurate staging. Deep tissue injuries appear as persistent dark purple or maroon discoloration indicating damage beneath intact skin. You should contact a lawyer at any stage, but Stage III, Stage IV, and unstageable wounds are particularly strong evidence of prolonged neglect. Even a Stage I or Stage II bedsore in a nursing home setting warrants investigation, as it indicates the facility is failing to implement basic prevention protocols.
Can a nursing home be sued for bedsores on Long Island?
Absolutely. New York Public Health Law §2801-d creates a private right of action allowing nursing home residents — or family members acting on their behalf — to sue any facility that deprives a resident of rights or benefits established by law, regulation, or code. Failure to prevent avoidable bedsores violates federal nursing home regulations (42 CFR §483.25), CMS F-tag F686, and the New York State minimum standards of care. You can pursue claims under PHL §2801-d (which allows compensatory damages plus a 25% punitive surcharge), common-law negligence, medical malpractice (if licensed medical professionals failed to order proper wound care), and wrongful death if the bedsore led to sepsis or other fatal complications. Our firm handles bedsore cases throughout Nassau County and Suffolk County, and we work on a contingency basis — you pay nothing unless we recover compensation.
How are bedsores prevented in nursing homes?
Evidence-based bedsore prevention protocols are well-established in the medical literature and required by federal and state regulations. The standard of care includes: repositioning immobile residents at least every two hours (and documenting each turn); using pressure-redistribution surfaces such as alternating-pressure mattresses and specialized wheelchair cushions; conducting daily skin assessments to identify early warning signs; maintaining adequate nutrition and hydration to support skin integrity — malnourished and dehydrated patients are at significantly higher risk; keeping skin clean and dry, particularly in incontinent residents; implementing individualized care plans that address each resident's specific risk factors; and providing physical therapy to maintain mobility where possible. When a facility fails to implement these basic measures, they are falling below the standard of care — and the resulting bedsores are legally considered avoidable and therefore evidence of negligence.
How much is a bedsore lawsuit worth?
The value of a bedsore lawsuit depends on the severity of the pressure ulcer, the extent of medical treatment required, whether the wound led to additional complications (infection, sepsis, amputation, death), and the degree of pain and suffering experienced by the resident. Stage III and Stage IV bedsores often require extensive medical intervention — wound vac therapy, surgical debridement, skin grafts, and prolonged hospital stays — and the associated medical costs alone can be substantial. Pain and suffering damages in advanced bedsore cases are significant because the wounds are excruciatingly painful, slow to heal, prone to infection, and deeply disfiguring. Cases involving wrongful death from bedsore-related sepsis carry additional damages including pre-death conscious pain and suffering, funeral costs, and loss of companionship. Under PHL §2801-d, courts may also impose a 25% punitive surcharge on compensatory damages. While every case is different, bedsore lawsuits involving advanced-stage wounds frequently reach six figures, and cases involving death or permanent disfigurement can reach seven figures.
Can bedsores cause death?
Yes, bedsores can be fatal. Advanced pressure ulcers — particularly Stage IV wounds that expose bone, muscle, and tendon — are open gateways for infection. The most dangerous complication is sepsis, a life-threatening systemic infection that occurs when bacteria from the wound enter the bloodstream. Sepsis can cause organ failure, septic shock, and death, particularly in elderly patients with compromised immune systems. Bedsores can also lead to osteomyelitis (bone infection), cellulitis (deep skin infection), and gangrene that may require amputation. According to medical literature, pressure ulcers are a contributing factor in approximately 60,000 deaths annually in the United States. When a nursing home resident dies from complications of a bedsore that developed due to inadequate care, the family may have grounds for a wrongful death lawsuit under EPTL §5-4.1 in addition to a PHL §2801-d claim against the facility.

Don’t Wait — Evidence Can Be Destroyed

Bedsores Are Preventable. When a Nursing Home Fails, We Hold Them Accountable.

Your loved one deserves proper care — not open wounds from neglect. Nursing homes alter records, destroy turning logs, and coach staff after complaints. Act now to preserve your case. The consultation is free.

No fee unless we win. Available 24/7. Hablamos Español.

Injured? Don't Wait.

Get Your Free Case Evaluation Today

No fees unless we win — available 24/7 for emergencies.

Call Now Free Review