Long Island Slip and
Fall Attorney

Understanding Slip and Fall Law in New York

Slip and fall accidents are among the most common personal injury claims on Long Island — and among the most misunderstood. Under New York law, property owners and occupiers have a legal duty to maintain their premises in a reasonably safe condition for visitors. When they fail to do so and someone is injured as a result, they can be held liable for damages under the state's premises liability framework.

The foundation of every slip and fall claim is the concept of duty of care. Property owners must regularly inspect their property, identify hazardous conditions, and either repair them promptly or provide adequate warning to visitors. This duty extends to business owners, landlords, property management companies, and in many cases, tenants who control the premises.

A critical element in New York slip and fall cases is notice. You must demonstrate that the property owner either had actual notice — meaning they knew about the hazard — or constructive notice, meaning the hazard existed long enough that a reasonable property owner should have discovered it through regular inspection. For example, if a puddle of water sat in a supermarket aisle for two hours without being cleaned up, the store likely had constructive notice. If an employee created the hazard or was told about it, that constitutes actual notice.

New York follows a pure comparative negligence system under CPLR Section 1411. This means you can still recover compensation even if you were partially at fault for your fall — your award is simply reduced by your percentage of responsibility. Even if a jury finds you 70% at fault, you still recover 30% of your damages. Insurance companies aggressively argue comparative fault in slip and fall cases, making experienced legal representation essential.

Claims against government property follow special rules. If you fell on a public sidewalk, in a county building, or at a municipal park, you must file a notice of claim within 90 days under General Municipal Law Section 50-e. Many Long Island towns also require "prior written notice" of sidewalk defects before the municipality can be held liable. The general statute of limitations for personal injury is three years from the date of the accident under CPLR Section 214.

Common Causes of Slip and Fall Accidents on Long Island

Slip and fall accidents occur in virtually every setting — from big-box retail stores to private homes. Understanding the common causes helps establish liability and strengthens your claim.

Wet or slippery floors

Spills in grocery stores, mopped floors in restaurants without warning signs, and leaking refrigeration units in retail establishments are among the most frequent causes. Property owners must either clean up spills promptly or place visible warning signs. Failure to do either establishes a strong basis for liability.

Snow and ice accumulation

Long Island winters create serious hazards on commercial parking lots, sidewalks, and building entrances. New York's "storm in progress" doctrine provides limited protection to property owners during an active storm, but once the storm ends, they must clear snow and ice within a reasonable time. Commercial property owners face stricter obligations than residential homeowners, and many Nassau and Suffolk County municipalities impose specific snow removal timelines.

Cracked or uneven sidewalks and walkways

Raised concrete slabs, tree root damage, and deteriorating pavement cause trip-and-fall injuries across Long Island. Liability may fall on the property owner, the municipality, or both — depending on local ordinances governing sidewalk maintenance responsibilities.

Poor lighting in stairwells, parking garages, and hallways

Inadequate lighting prevents visitors from seeing steps, changes in elevation, or obstacles in their path. Landlords of apartment buildings and owners of commercial parking structures have a particular duty to maintain proper illumination in high-traffic areas where falls are foreseeable.

Missing or broken handrails

Building codes require handrails on stairs and ramps for a reason. When a handrail is missing, loose, or improperly installed, a fall victim has a strong argument that the property owner violated a specific safety standard — which can help establish negligence as a matter of law.

Loose carpeting or floor mats

Bunched-up entry mats, frayed carpet edges, and improperly secured area rugs create tripping hazards in commercial buildings, hotels, and apartment complexes. These defects are often well-known to the property owner long before an injury occurs.

Construction debris or obstacles in walkways

Building materials, tools, and temporary barriers left in pedestrian paths create foreseeable hazards. Construction companies and property owners share liability for injuries caused by failure to secure work sites and maintain clear walking paths.

Potholes in parking lots

Deteriorating asphalt in commercial parking lots causes both vehicle damage and pedestrian injuries. Property owners who fail to repair or mark known potholes can be held liable, particularly when the hazard has existed long enough to constitute constructive notice.

Injuries We See in Slip and Fall Cases

Slip and fall injuries range from painful but temporary to life-altering. The severity of your injury directly impacts the value of your claim and the type of compensation available.

Broken bones and fractures

Wrist fractures from bracing a fall, ankle fractures from uneven surfaces, and hip fractures from hard impacts are extremely common. Hip fractures are especially serious for elderly victims — they often require surgical repair, extended rehabilitation, and can lead to permanent mobility limitations or accelerated decline in overall health.

Traumatic brain injuries and concussions

Hitting your head during a fall can cause concussions, contusions, or more severe traumatic brain injuries (TBI). Symptoms may not appear for hours or days after the accident. TBIs can result in cognitive difficulties, personality changes, chronic headaches, and long-term disability that fundamentally alters your quality of life.

Spinal cord injuries and herniated discs

The force of a fall can herniate discs in the cervical or lumbar spine, causing radiating pain, numbness, and weakness. Severe spinal cord injuries may result in partial or complete paralysis. These injuries frequently require surgery, extensive physical therapy, and long-term pain management.

Torn ligaments

ACL tears, MCL injuries, and rotator cuff tears are common when the body twists or absorbs impact during a fall. These injuries often require arthroscopic surgery followed by months of rehabilitation and may result in permanent joint instability or chronic pain.

Soft tissue injuries

Sprains, strains, and deep contusions may not show up on X-rays but can cause significant pain and limited mobility for weeks or months. Insurance companies often downplay these injuries, but the impact on your daily life and ability to work can be substantial.

Cuts, lacerations, and knee injuries

Deep cuts requiring stitches can leave permanent scarring. Knee injuries from falls — including meniscus tears and patellar fractures — frequently require surgical intervention and can impair mobility for years, affecting both your career and your ability to enjoy everyday activities.

Proving Your Slip and Fall Case

Winning a slip and fall case requires more than showing you fell and were hurt. You must establish each of the four elements of negligence, and you must do it with evidence that holds up against aggressive defense tactics.

The four elements are: (1) the property owner owed you a duty of care, (2) they breached that duty by allowing a dangerous condition, (3) the dangerous condition caused your fall and resulting injuries, and (4) you suffered quantifiable damages. The most contested element in most premises liability cases is proving the property owner had notice of the hazard.

Critical evidence includes surveillance footage — which is often the single most important piece of evidence in a slip and fall case. Most commercial properties have security cameras, but footage is typically overwritten every 30 to 60 days. Requesting that footage immediately through a spoliation letter is one of the first things our firm does. We also pursue incident reports filed with the property owner, witness statements, photographs of the hazard and your injuries, weather records for ice and snow cases, and maintenance logs showing how often the property was inspected.

Expert witnesses play an important role in complex cases. Engineers can testify about building code violations, slip resistance of flooring materials, and inadequate drainage systems. Medical professionals establish the connection between the fall and your injuries, the necessity of treatment, and the long-term prognosis for your recovery.

Insurance companies fight slip and fall claims aggressively. Their common tactics include denying the property owner had any notice of the hazard, arguing you were distracted or not paying attention, claiming the hazard was "open and obvious" and you should have avoided it, and disputing the severity of your injuries by pointing to gaps in medical treatment. Having an attorney who knows these tactics — and how to counter them — makes a meaningful difference in the outcome of your case.

What to Do After a Slip and Fall on Long Island

The steps you take in the hours and days after a fall directly affect the strength of your legal claim. Follow these steps to protect your rights:

Types of Properties Where Slip and Falls Occur

Premises liability claims arise on virtually every type of property. The specific legal standards and liable parties differ depending on the property classification.

Commercial properties

Shopping centers, malls, big-box stores like Costco and Walmart, restaurants, and office buildings see the highest volume of slip and fall claims. Commercial property owners owe the highest duty of care to customers and business invitees. They must conduct regular inspections, maintain clean floors, provide adequate lighting, and promptly address any hazards. Across Nassau and Suffolk Counties, we regularly handle claims against national retailers, local businesses, and commercial landlords.

Residential properties

Apartment buildings, condominium complexes, and rental units present unique liability issues. Landlords are generally responsible for maintaining common areas — lobbies, stairwells, hallways, and parking areas. In New York, tenants may have a claim against their landlord for injuries caused by known defects that the landlord failed to repair despite having notice.

Government property

Falls on public sidewalks, in government buildings, and at municipal parks require special handling. The 90-day notice of claim requirement is strictly enforced. For sidewalk defects, many Long Island towns follow the "prior written notice" rule — meaning the municipality must have been formally notified of the specific defect before your fall. Without that written complaint on file, your claim against the town or village may be barred entirely. Our firm investigates municipal records to determine whether prior written notice exists.

Workplaces

Falls in offices, warehouses, and construction sites may give rise to both workers' compensation claims and third-party personal injury lawsuits. If your fall was caused by a third party's negligence — such as a building owner or general contractor — you may be entitled to compensation beyond what workers' comp provides. New York Labor Law Sections 240 and 241 provide additional protections for construction workers injured in falls from heights.

Private residences

Homeowners can be liable for injuries to guests at parties, gatherings, or social events. If a guest falls on a broken step, a wet deck, or a poorly lit walkway, the homeowner's liability insurance may cover the claim. Homeowner policies typically include premises liability coverage, making these claims viable even when the property owner is a friend or family member.

How Insurance Companies Fight Slip and Fall Claims

Insurance companies treat slip and fall cases as high-priority targets for denial or reduction. Understanding their tactics is essential to protecting the value of your claim.

The most common defense is denying notice. The insurer argues the property owner had no way of knowing about the hazard. They will claim the spill happened moments before your fall, that no complaints were ever filed about the sidewalk defect, or that the ice formed too recently for anyone to have addressed it. Our firm counters this by subpoenaing maintenance logs, inspection schedules, and employee records that show how long the condition actually existed.

Insurers also routinely argue you were distracted — looking at your phone, not watching where you walked, or wearing inappropriate footwear. They use the "open and obvious" defense, claiming the hazard was so visible that you should have seen it and avoided it. While New York does not follow a strict "open and obvious" bar, comparative fault arguments can reduce your recovery.

Post-accident surveillance is another common tactic. Insurers hire investigators to follow you, photograph you carrying groceries or playing with your children, and use that footage to argue your injuries are not as severe as claimed. They also monitor your social media — a single photo of you smiling at a family event can be taken out of context to undermine your pain and suffering claim.

Perhaps most damaging are lowball settlement offers made early in the process, before you understand the full extent of your injuries. Accepting a quick $10,000 offer for what turns out to be a herniated disc requiring surgery would leave hundreds of thousands of dollars on the table. Having an experienced attorney ensures you don't settle before you know what your case is actually worth.

About Jason Tenenbaum, Esq.

Jason Tenenbaum has represented injured Long Islanders since 2002. With over 24 years of experience in personal injury and premises liability law, he brings a depth of knowledge that comes only from decades of handling these cases in Nassau and Suffolk County courts.

Unlike many firms that hand off appeals and trial work to separate attorneys, Jason writes his own appeals — over 500 to date — and tries his own cases. The attorney who knows your file is the one standing in front of the judge. This continuity means nothing falls through the cracks, and the legal strategy remains consistent from your first consultation through resolution.

Jason's deep familiarity with local courts, judges, and insurance defense firms across Long Island gives his clients a strategic advantage. He leads a team of experienced attorneys supported by multilingual staff who serve the diverse communities of Nassau and Suffolk Counties. Whether your case requires aggressive negotiation or courtroom advocacy, you get the full weight of his experience behind your claim.