No-Fault Claim Denials

What Do I Do When My Claim Has Been Denied?

Insurance carriers who deny your no-fault claim in New York count on you giving up without a fight. At the Law Office of Jason Tenenbaum, P.C., we have built our reputation on turning denied claims into approved ones by compelling insurance companies to reveal their inconsistent handling practices.

Going Beyond Basic Legal Arguments

Standard responses to no-fault claim denials often fall short. While other firms may settle for surface-level documentation, we pursue a far more thorough approach. We demand that insurance carriers produce:

• Every page of your claims file
• Their Special Investigation Unit (SIU) records
• Documentation of similar cases they have handled in arbitration

This comprehensive approach provides the evidence we need to mount an effective challenge on your behalf.

How We Hold Insurance Companies Accountable

Your insurance company likely provided what appears to be a legitimate reason for denying your claim. However, we have seen repeatedly how these denials often stem from unfair practices. By obtaining the complete record—including how the carrier has handled other cases similar to yours—we can:

• Identify patterns in their denial decisions
• Demonstrate how they have approved comparable claims
• Challenge the integrity of their investigation methods
• Reveal where they have violated their own internal protocols

Breaking Down the Documentation

Each category of documentation we demand serves a specific purpose in building your case:

What Your Claims File Reveals

We examine every detail to uncover:

• Internal communications between adjusters regarding your case
• The timeline and basis for each decision
• Their assessment of your medical needs
• Whether they followed proper claims-handling procedures

What We Learn from SIU Files

These investigation records often reveal:

• The thoroughness—or lack thereof—of their investigation into your claim
• The methods and criteria employed during the review
• Any bias or predetermined conclusions in their process
• Whether they complied with applicable state regulations

Why Prior Case Outcomes Matter

Analyzing the carrier’s handling of similar cases allows us to:

• Expose contradictions in their decision-making
• Demonstrate patterns of unjustified denials
• Establish evidence of discriminatory or inconsistent conduct
• Construct more persuasive arguments on your behalf

Our Litigation Strategy

We follow a methodical process to challenge your denial and pursue every available avenue for recovery.

Why Our Approach Succeeds

Most claimants accept a denial at face value—which is precisely what insurance companies count on. We take a fundamentally different approach by:

• Requiring the carrier to justify every adverse decision
• Highlighting their inconsistent claims-handling practices
• Creating meaningful leverage for settlement negotiations
• Substantially improving the likelihood of a favorable outcome

What Sets Us Apart

We prevail in these cases because we are willing to do the work that others will not. Behind every denial is an individual who needs medical care or a provider who deserves payment for services rendered. That commitment drives our firm to pursue every case with vigor.

When you choose the Law Office of Jason Tenenbaum, P.C., you are working with a team that:

• Possesses deep knowledge of New York no-fault insurance law
• Has developed proven strategies for overturning claim denials
• Recognizes and effectively counters standard insurance defense tactics
• Treats every client’s case with personal dedication

Ready to Challenge Your Denial?

Do not let an insurance company’s denial be the final word on your claim. Contact the Law Office of Jason Tenenbaum, P.C. today to discuss how we can help overturn your denial.

Our aggressive, evidence-driven approach has helped numerous clients obtain the compensation they rightfully deserve. You have rights under New York law, and we will help you assert them. Together, we will challenge your no-fault claim denial head-on.

Local Expertise

Deep familiarity with Nassau and Suffolk County courts, judges, and insurance defense tactics.

No Fee Unless We Win

You pay nothing upfront—we only collect a fee when you receive compensation.

Medical Network

Access to leading Long Island medical specialists who understand proper injury documentation.

24/7 Availability

Emergency support whenever you need us—nights, weekends, and holidays.

Proven Track Record

Millions recovered for clients in no-fault and personal injury cases across Long Island.

Personalized Attention

We treat every case with the care and focus it deserves, ensuring your voice is heard.