The missing video

Fox v Grand Slam Banquet Hall, 2016 NY Slip Op 05897 (1st Dept. 2016)

(1) “Under the particular circumstances of this case, the court abused its discretion in [*2]dismissing the complaint due to plaintiff’s belated disclosure of a video. Although CPLR 3101(i) requires disclosure of “any films, photographs, video tapes or audio tapes” of a party upon demand (see Falk v Inzinna , 299 AD2d 120 [2d Dept 2002]), there was insufficient evidence of willful or contumacious conduct on plaintiff’s part, or prejudice to Grand Slam, to warrant the dismissal of her complaint in the midst of the jury trial (see Colome v Grand Concourse 2075 , 302 AD2d 251 [1st Dept 2003]; Ahroni v City of New York , 175 AD2d 789 [2d Dept 1991]), even if the dismissal was without prejudice.”

(2) “There was no court order directing plaintiff to produce the video, and Grand Slam’s discovery demands only requested that she produce photographs. Furthermore, plaintiff, who claimed to have misplaced the video, did not seek to introduce the edited video, which did not show her fall, into evidence at trial, and was willing to consent to its preclusion, the striking of her testimony concerning its existence, and a curative instruction, even though she believed the video to be favorable to her because it showed a cord across the floor and one of Grand Slam’s principals standing in the vicinity.”

This literally was the trial surprise and the court was not going to entertain it.  I can see Judge Gonzalez striking the complaint.  Calmer minds in downtown Manhattan gave the plaintiff a break.  I am unsure I would have been so generous to the plaintiff.

Facebook
Twitter
Email
Print
Practice Areas

Our wide-ranging expertise will provide you with well-rounded legal counsel

At the Law Office of Jason Tenenbaum, our attorneys have the integrity and experience you need to best assist, advise, and support you through your legal challenge, every step of the way.

No Fault Defense
Practice Areas
No Fault Defense

Using cutting-edge technology and strategy to solve complicated problems.

Woman in the hospital with injured leg
Practice Areas
Personal Injury

We can fight for your pain and suffering, lost income, medical bills, and any future lost wages.

Upset woman in the front of the computer with bills
Practice Areas
Medical Malpractice

You have the right to bring a malpractice claim for your medical expenses, lost income and pain and suffering.

Card in the hand
Practice Areas
Consumer Protection

If you have been sued for an unpaid consumer loan, fallen behind on your credit card bills or similar.

Court room
Practice Areas
Commercial Litigation

We can help when you are faced with commercial litigation issues.

We dedicate ourselves to important values

We work hard to fight for your individual case and rights, while providing superior legal services on a timely, effective, and efficient basis. 

Need Help With Your Case?

Proin rhoncus metus aliquet blandit ad placerat sociosqu erat vel letius scelerisque taciti pulvinar.

Got Questions?

Proin rhoncus metus aliquet blandit ad placerat sociosqu erat vel letius scelerisque taciti pulvinar.